quarantine has made me many things, but concise is apparently not one of them lmao
apologies for the truly obscene amount of text that's incoming
@crocs
the poem: fabulous. uplifting. confident. imagery is on point.
Favourite lines:
Because I can see myself that way,
Narcissus’ hand in mine,
Showing me how lovely my perfections
And imperfections are.
the last lines are usually the ones I'm most picky and pedantic about. and can I just say you've absolutely nailed them this time?? they honestly read like a mic drop. the Narcissus thing is just. yes.
I couldn't really find much to say? there were a few bits where I wonder if the wording is actually a bit awkward or if it's just my way of reading it. So for example, is the "in" in "I'm comfortable, in knowing this" necessary? Is there a smoother way of saying "drawing forth an urge"? idk man.
A few lines where I wonder if they're worded as effectively as possible would be
I have given myself routine
Where I used to not have one.
And that is something incredible.
idk how to explain this very well, but would it make sense to build up to "routine" rather than starting with it? like start with how you didn't have one before, give an indication of how incredible it is, and then end with "I have given myself routine" as like a final oomph of "yeah I'm awesome". It's like you start with the need to accomplish it and then end on the fact that it has been accomplished?
idk it makes sense in my head. but feel free to ignore this weird rambly attempt at coherence
the prose: here's actual footage of me reading this
it's so pure?? I ship them so hard?? their dynamic is so perfect?? fdshjfkdhsj
I'm pretty sure this is just because I don't know any context and so foreshadowing goes right over my head, but it feels like there's sometimes a lack of focus? in the narration. from what I can tell, the first bit is meant to be Kasper reminiscing about how he met Jo and how much Jo means to him as he's sitting at his bedside. but we're hearing all about Ireland and how the town is just this side of strange and mice and as a reader I'm left wondering how much of that is strictly necessary.
it could also just be super good characterisation of Kasper's thought process, if he's anything like I imagine him to be, tbh.
anyway, thank you for blessing us doubly this week
@Icefire_married_two_people
you consistently take pleasure in breaking my heart in 600 words or less huh. that's just the tiiiniest bit sadistic of you. but it means your writing is very effective!! Strong sentence structure, strong images, generally high tension that feels vivid and real.
Like crocs said, the main thing I noticed is that this would really benefit from being longer. It's great as is, but there's just a lot of backstory and exposition being dropped in quite a short time, which can detract from the tension and what's happening in the moment. It would also allow for less exposition through dialogue, which I feel would leave more room for characterisation, more room to work on their unique voice and give hints into their dynamic.
and of course, the last bit presents a huge shift in narrative style, which makes sense since the original pov character dies. but it's just a tiny bit jarring to suddenly move into omniscience, and then arguably into Lex's perspective.
but yeah, I get that this was just an in the moment writing exercise. so it was really, really well done.
@izzy-is-a-depressed-idiot
I really love this!! you've chosen some really strong images, really strong word choice, and a structure that isn't overloaded with unnecessary words, so the images can really shine.
Favourite lines:
The sun outside lit up the water
Lighting up the massive columns underwater
Holding up the bridge-like structure outdoors
One thing I noticed is a slight bit of ambiguity in the third stanza. the lack of punctuation meant that at first I thought "only the small lights" was meant to be in the same sentence as "the darkness surrounded" rather than the beginning of a new one. So maybe there's a way to clarify what exactly the darkness surrounded, and that would clear up the rest of the stanza and improve the flow.
but yeah, this was really great!! thank you so much for sharing!
@Dances_with_Shadows-the-spooky-midget
both of these are excellent!!
the text: I'm living for this characterisation. Theresa sounds like an intense, self-aware, sassy, salty, brilliant character, and it comes across really well in the way she lays everything out. One thing I wondered as it went along was how intensely personal this was for having no single audience and for being like… band contact with fans, but I'm assuming that that makes sense in the context of the greater story I'm not aware of. I assume there's a context where this isn't as wildly oversharing as it would be in the one I'm thinking of.
not much else to say about this, tbh, except that I really enjoyed it.
the character: very detailed, very thorough, very well-laid out and believable. There's backstory and context for his mannerisms, and the explanations all link together so that while he's complex and faceted, there's enough consistency for it all to link up.
some questions I had as I read through it:
- what does he do for a living? I'm assuming at 21 he's done with school, but I'm not 100% sure where he is, whether he lives at home, what his day to day looks like, and what kind of context he's operating in. I'm sure this is obvious to you, and ultimately the character sheet is meant to be for you, so idk that it would benefit from adding this to it in the end.
- Where was Valka throughout the incident? where was she the night Rowan died? (speaking of - why was there no opportunity to give her medical attention, if she survived throughout the entire night and only died the next morning?) they seem to have a really strong mutually affectionate relationship, and yet the way his struggle is portrayed makes it seem like he went through it almost alone, without much support. How does she feel about the drastic change in his personality?
- in his personality, you mentioned that "he doesn't do anything without seeing if it's either worth the effort and time or if he'll get something out of it". what would make something "worth it" for him? what sorts of things is he looking to gain? does he have any long-term goals or things he wants to achieve?
overall, he's already a super developed and fleshed out character. so feel free to ignore these questions if they don't add anything significant.
thanks so much for sharing!!