forum Don't Be Suspicious
Started by Deleted user
tune
Edit topic

people_alt 113 followers

Deleted user

Ooh, hey Dom! I didn't know you were back!

Hey Miriam! Just came back a few hours ago. We’ll see how often I’ll stay but hopefully a lot. Mutters darkly about a Driver’s license and college tests.

<3

@HighPockets group

I’ll sum is up because I don’t want to make this too long. And correct it if I am wrong as I am not fully educated but have only seen many opinions.
She is a better pilot then everyone else, even in vehicles she’s never flown before.
Better shot and only misses once even with ships never before used.
Hella force strength without training.
Really good lightsaber weilder and is better than everyone except one Grand Jedi Master for a bit even when he had killed other Jedi still without training.
She is oh so good.
Immediately liked except by people we are supposed to dislike and the guy who committed suicide while and then she robs him and that is supposed to be good.
The world is hugely bent around her as power comes with training yet she has unprecedented levels of power nonetheless. (Barring dudes like Yoda who had trained forever.)
She is the main focus whenever on screen, even making the villain drop the search for the map that is his main objective because of her, as well as making the defected stormtrooper at odds with his backstory as well as making a central character ignore already existent friendships to put critical story needs on her shoulders after first meeting.
She’s the best and the support characters only get a chance to shine when she is out of the screen.
She faces no true difficulty and wins no matter the odds.

  • Incorrect, Poe Dameron and Han Solo are better pilots, and she's used a flight simulator since the age of 12
  • Finn was the one who was shooting the Falcon, not Rey.
    -…..yeah, that's how the force works. So was Anakin. And Ezra.
  • She fought with a melee weapon her whole life, and if you pay attention, her technique is really sloppy. And the 1 guy she beat had just been shot in the chest with a heavy-duty weapon and was still reeling from killing his father
  • Not really?
  • When was that? I've seen TFA like 5 times and don't remember someone committing suicide and Rey robbing him
  • Mmmm not really. We see that she's gifted and we see her train later. She has raw power, that's it.
  • Yeah, because she's the protagonist. They tend to be the focus.
  • Again, she's the protagonist. That's what happens with protagonists. And we see plenty of badassery from everyone.
  • She got her ass kicked by Kylo at first and got slammed into a tree, then only won because he was weak and injured from Chewie and Finn, but sure.

@HighPockets group

And that's just covering The Force Awakens, not to mention how she trains in The Last Jedi and still could barely fight 1 guard while Kylo took on 3. And how she had to face the harsh truth about her parents, and how she was tossed around by Snoke, and how she wasn't even the one to land the killing blow on him, or the one who ended the battle of Crait. Or that she willingly went along with Kylo in the force bond and still wasn't able to convince him to take her side.

@Althalosian-is-the-father book

I’ll sum is up because I don’t want to make this too long. And correct it if I am wrong as I am not fully educated but have only seen many opinions.
She is a better pilot then everyone else, even in vehicles she’s never flown before.
Better shot and only misses once even with ships never before used.
Hella force strength without training.
Really good lightsaber weilder and is better than everyone except one Grand Jedi Master for a bit even when he had killed other Jedi still without training.
She is oh so good.
Immediately liked except by people we are supposed to dislike and the guy who committed suicide while and then she robs him and that is supposed to be good.
The world is hugely bent around her as power comes with training yet she has unprecedented levels of power nonetheless. (Barring dudes like Yoda who had trained forever.)
She is the main focus whenever on screen, even making the villain drop the search for the map that is his main objective because of her, as well as making the defected stormtrooper at odds with his backstory as well as making a central character ignore already existent friendships to put critical story needs on her shoulders after first meeting.
She’s the best and the support characters only get a chance to shine when she is out of the screen.
She faces no true difficulty and wins no matter the odds.

  • Incorrect, Poe Dameron and Han Solo are better pilots, and she's used a flight simulator since the age of 12
  • Finn was the one who was shooting the Falcon, not Rey.
    -…..yeah, that's how the force works. So was Anakin. And Ezra.
  • She fought with a melee weapon her whole life, and if you pay attention, her technique is really sloppy. And the 1 guy she beat had just been shot in the chest with a heavy-duty weapon and was still reeling from killing his father
  • Not really?
  • When was that? I've seen TFA like 5 times and don't remember someone committing suicide and Rey robbing him
  • Mmmm not really. We see that she's gifted and we see her train later. She has raw power, that's it.
  • Yeah, because she's the protagonist. They tend to be the focus.
  • Again, she's the protagonist. That's what happens with protagonists. And we see plenty of badassery from everyone.
  • She got her ass kicked by Kylo at first and got slammed into a tree, then only won because he was weak and injured from Chewie and Finn, but sure.

Nice defense!
Protagonist is the hero of their story, not the universe. She shouldn’t have been the focus of Kylo because he was on his find Luke quest.
Idk about Ezra and don’t consider him cannon. And sure, Anakin was really strong. But he had what? Ten years of training before he did anything besides have heightened senses? Same with Luke. He was Anakin “the most amazing ever blablaba’s” son. And Rey was way stronger than him. That seems wrong. Especially since it was demonstrated in the originals that even though Luke had amazing potential, he was still really really weak until Yoda trained him. So I think the OP biz still stands.
And has she ever done anything stupid (and had to pay for it?)
Also I believe the suicide guy is Luke.
And who trained her?

@HighPockets group

You need to consider Ezra canon because he literally is? Rey isn't stronger than Anakin, no one is stronger than Anakin.
Luke doesn't commit suicide? She gets trained by Luke Fucking Skywalker in The Last Jedi. Personally I think it's unfair that you're judging her when you haven't even seen the second movie she was in, and the third isn't even out yet. Her arc isn't complete yet, especially not for you.

@HighPockets group

Upon meeting a 9 year old Anakin, Qui-Gon could instantly tell that he was force-sensitive. He not only survived but won in a sport that was impossible for normal humans, and then made a near-impossible shot to destroy the Trade Federation shuttle. When he was 9 and had no training or education of any kind.

@Althalosian-is-the-father book

Personally I think it's unfair that you're judging her when you haven't even seen the second movie she was in, and the third isn't even out yet. Her arc isn't complete yet, especially not for you.

Solid points. I withdraw.

Deleted user

Also- to jump in at the last second here: Let's not forget that Rey is a Disney Character, she is specifically written to not have much dare I say personality simply because the studio that controls her, focuses mainly on it's female characters leaning towards the 'meek-goodie-two-shoes' stereotype. Which you can plainly see in the complete character destruction of Leia in the recent movies.

Deleted user

So yea, she may be a bit of a Mary Sue but she's meant to be that way so young children (Disney's main audience) can 'relate' enough to her so they can make a profit. Her arch could have been way, way more focused into something truly strong and badass, but that is just not the type of studio that Disney is.

Luke has always been a bland Gary Stu. Fite me.