@tomat brightness_7
Hello! If you are still open to do this could you do Otis? His backstory and some relationships is still a work in progress so any and all critiques are good! Lately he has been bordering Mary Sue territory as well so just a heads up for that……if you have any questions I got you
understood. if his backstory and relationships have little information written, I won't rate them.
Overview - 89/100
ooh, demon characters are nice, I wonder how you've written him. and judging by my quick glance on his sections, you've written A LOT. like, wow, there are so many words in his relationships. I get a feeling that I'll spend a long time on him.
Looks - 90/100
I suppose that the only thing that differentiates him from humans are his eyes. is there something more? if he's among humans, does he hide his demon traits, and vice versa? or maybe he doesn't have to hide anything?
Nature - 95/100
his mannerisms are very well-written! although, I'd like to know more about his "demonic side". maybe I'll find it in "Race" or "Magic" section.
I'm so curious about his backstory
okay he's definitely going to be my friend
"I want to say…" then say it. don't be afraid.
I see nothing troublesome here, but I can give you some advice if you're concerned about that "Mary Sue territory". firstly, define your characters' virtues, and then stretch them so far that they become flaws. if they're always honest, make them afraid to tell lies, and then put them into a situation where they have to deceive someone. after that, watch them panic and find a solution. remember that virtues and flaws should be balanced, but even more flaws are accepted. to be sure that they definitely aren't Mary Sue, make them fail or do something wrong in your story. make them misunderstand something, break down from their responsibilities, push them far beyond their limits. there must be a situation from which the character can't come out with no effort. I hope that I've explained it well because this is my limit of English language. good luck ^-^
History - 80/100
after you finish writing his history, I advise you to reread it to correct some minor mistakes.
I really liked that part of him becoming a Royal Messenger! I didn't quite expect that!
his backstory is good, not minding the mistakes. I hope that you'll write the part that you missed soon, and determine more of Otis' traits from it!
Social - 96/100
what exactly is "Guardian religion"?
"Quetzil" this is such an interesting name, can I have an exemplary sentence of this language?
Pasta Yes
woah that necklace must be pretty
💜❤️💚frogs💚❤️💜
Relationships - 98/100
oh boy here we go
his mother's relationship is good, but I get a feeling that it's written a bit more from her perspective. it's Otis' page, so I think that majority should be written from his POV.
I admire that you put so much thought into his relationships. it really helps me to understand Otis and I feel like I've known him for 5 years at least
he is such a good brother
the same as "History" here, reread when you finish and correct mistakes.
is impressed
I admire your effort. I think I'm going to… checks notes …take a leaf out of your book. wow I just learned a new idiom (wisdom +5, self-appraisal +10)
and I even get to know more about your other characters! that's great!
Goddess? who's that?
Race/species - 85/100
"not be able to react strongly or understand emotional cues". is that me? insert meme maybe I am a demon.
Magic - 93/100
I hope you'll find that list quickly!
everything's nice here but remember to not make him too op!
wow, Otis is surely a very developed character! it was a pleasure reading about him. when you finish his history and relationships, I think there will be nothing more necessary to add to his page! you did a great job, you've made me impressed and curious about his later story, and you've made Otis such a likeable character! be proud!
average - 90/100
Otis is:
98% likely to be my friend
78% likely to by my lover
83% likely to be my party member
48% likely to be my enemy