forum free character critiques (closed temporarily)
Started by @WriteOutofTime
tune

people_alt 13 followers

@Kinarymo

@writelikeyourerunningoutoftime thank you for the reply! i was getting a little nervous since it's the first time i've ever asked someone to criticize Narion :'D
You did point out some important problems and i'll try fix them any way i can. However, there were certain parts where i feel like you may have skipped some bits of information, but i'm going to answer some of your questions anyway :D

Looks
Narion has animal ears because on one side, she is believed to be a human – spirit halfbreed, and in this universe, spirits are usually humanoid creatures with features that indicate the animal they once were. So for example, an average fox spirit will have the body of a human, but the ears, tail and legs of a fox. So if she was indeed a human – spirit mix, she would only inherit certain features – like the ears (obviously, the ears are there for a good reason :V) Since she can’t see, she relies more on her hearing and the fact that they’re large and mobile gives her a more clear sound reception.
In reality, she’s not a mix, she’s part from a different specie. I talked about it in the „specie” folder i added, since i do not have access to the Specie feature this app has (need to pay fo dat) – i did not finish this section it’s still a work in progress. Her specie has something like a „true form” where they are more animal-like, with ears and all. They rarely show that form though, as they consider it too intimidating, so they took a different, more human-like form as to not scare people. Some of their original features have stayed, such as the ears and the large canines, while other did not.
The reason why Narion is confused with a human-spirit mix is because her specie was hunted down into extinction by humans long ago, so people get confused as to what she is.

Nature
Yeah, i’m still working very hard on this one since it’s still not good enough. But thank you for pointing it out! I’ve done some plot changing lately, so now i need to give them new motivations as well. She sticks with Tanis because he’s the only one who showed her how much he truly appreciates her, so she has some trust in him. Narion also helps Tanis because even though he keeps telling her he’ll protect her from anything, in reality she’s the stronger one, so basically she needs to be there to get him out of trouble. And yes, Narion is aware of how small she is and her inability to see, but she tries to use this in her advantage (like, you cannot use visual distractions on someone who cannot see).

Social
She’s just not interested in politics, she’s a kid and she has her own problems to worry about. As for the government, she’s not really fond of it either. There is one supreme ruler, who isn’t liked by many people because of how much the humans have expanded their territory under his rain and with them, they brought along many problems for the other native species. Many creatures were forced to leave, others have to live close to humans, which is not a very pleasant thing for them and some were even hunted into extinction, like Narion’s specie.

History
I’m getting the feeling you may have not read this section very carefully, as i did specify she was found by TANIS’s PARENTS and that she is in the care of an ADOPTIVE FAMILY. But please correct me if i’m wrong. Tanis also gets mentioned several times in different sections, including the background. They’re not related by blood, but their relationship is very strong. Being the only person left in his family after their parents were supposedly kidnapped, Narion means a lot to Tanis and he really tries his absolute best to keep her safe and happy. He’s also worried that she might eventually die because of her constant health problems, so naturally, he feels the need to help her in every way he can

Thanks for your help ^w^

@mellowlynea

@writelikeyourerunningoutoftime
Thank you! It is hard to judge chemistry without seeing them interact, and yes, One is entirely capable of love! They are from a society where emotions and hormonal responses pertaining to mood are controlled with "peacekeepers" for optimal peace and a harmonic society. That does not mean they aren't there! One has never experienced individuality, love for love's sake, and emotional interaction, which is why they are learning from Tobias! As the two get along better (trust me, it will take a while of stilted interactions and arguments) they discover things about each other and themselves, and fall in love. It's the kind of slow burn that takes aaaaaages. One has a personality, it just takes a bit of digging for it to come out! I'll keep it in mind, though. Thank you for the praise!! <3

@WriteOutofTime

I honestly live for in-depth responses to my critiques! It really clears stuff up and (I'm hoping) helps you get your thoughts on paper. @Kohaku I think my problem was you never explicitly state who Tanis is to her. Now that I've read over it, keeping in mind Tanis and her brother are one in the same, it does make sense. My bad.

@mellowlynea I am a huge fan of a slow burn romance! Good luck.

@WriteOutofTime

@writelikeyourerunningoutoftime, I don't have a character for you to critique, but I was working on creating more diverse characters that I can use for future story ideas and roleplays. If you (or anyone else) has any quirks, character name, personality ideas, or appearances for some characters that I could use, that would be great. Thank you!

Here's a list of random mannerisms I wrote…some time ago.
dances a little whenever they're excited
likes to stack random objects to see how high they can stack before tumbling down
doodling on their hands/wrists
tapping their feet under their desk
whenever they're in an empty aisle in a store, they do something stupid like cartwheel or dance or spin
tugs at their ear when nervous
talks to themselves when they think no one can hear
sings to themselves
hums to themselves
tugs at their eyebrows/eyelashes when nervous
peels at the skin around their nails when anxious/upset
smiles when they're sad to keep from crying
clenches their teeth absentmindedly
plays with their friend's hair

@WriteOutofTime

Hey, could you look at my character? Gabrielle Strasser
By the way, the story I'm writing has several narrators that end up in the story itself. It's a bit complicated, but Gabrielle is one of the narrators.

This is still on private, btw

@WriteOutofTime

So, I'm definitely going to critique all these characters. Buuut with 4th of july coming up, I'm going to have a lot of family start to roll into town. Critiques will be slow. Sorry for the wait.

@Bremston

@HumanTailSans
In order for people to be able to look at your character, you need to make it public. Click the share option, then change the character from private to public.

@Bremston

@Garbage
Loved the detail you put into this character. I only have one problem:
Looking at her weight and height, she is very overweight. The typical weight for her height is 72-88 lbs, but she is 113 lbs. Considering that she is small and weak, I would make her 78 lbs. at most. Other than that, I don't really have much to say on her looks.

@WriteOutofTime

Hi! Could you look over this OC for me?

Hi! I'm finally back from my hiatus to critique your character. I'm not really the best at critiquing fanfiction characters since I'm not a fanfiction writer myself, but I'll try my best.

Looks
For the weight section: google is free! Look up average weights for teens, average weights for girls who are 5'5, etc. Also, what's her natural hair color? How long is her hair? China blue is kind of an unusual eye color, but that's just me being nit-picky. For the most part, her appearance seems fine.

Nature
Her mannerisms…aren't really mannerisms. Mannerisms are small actions repeated habitually and somewhat subconsciously. So biting lips, biting fingernails, twirling hair –all mannerisms. Adding in mannerisms is a quick way to humanize a character, so be sure to brainstorm a few mannerisms and try to include them. For her motivation, what is it about her friend Piper that motivates her? Does she want to keep her save? Help her? Why is it part of her motivation? Why does she want to help the world? I really like her flaws! They're quite realistic and consistent. Here's the definition of prejudice: a preconceived opinion that is not based on reason or actual experience. So your character's prejudice should be a preconceived notion they possess about other people/things. Not how people view her. Does she have any talents irrelevant to the story? Sometimes it helps to flesh out a character if you add a few seemingly trivial details. Her hobbies are pretty good, but you could add a bit more in the personality type. Try to illustrate how she acts on a day-to-day basis. How does she act around family vs friends vs strangers? What's her sense of humor like? How much does it take to make her angry? To make her cry?

Social
When you say she has no opinion on politics, what do you mean exactly? Why doesn't she care about current events? Does she have any opinion on the government/her country at all? Is she an advocate for equality? Otherwise, very good job on this section!

History
Her background is painfully bare. No offense, but it seems mighty convenient that her parents died and she was taken in by the main characters of the Flash. Why did they adopt her? How did she react at first? What was her reaction to her parents deaths? How old was she when it happened? How was she raised? What was her childhood like?

Overall, pretty solid character! Again, I'm no fanfiction writer, so I don't know what the norm is (like, is it weird to have your OC 'related' to the main characters??), but I think Blu has potential. Good luck :D

@WriteOutofTime

Heya! Could you please take a look at my characters? I'm not so sure if they're good enough, so they might need some criticizing. Thanks a lot ;w;

Finally getting around to your second character, Tanthaliel! This critique will likely be rather small as you've done a great job adding in details and fleshing out his character. On to the critique!

Nature
His mannerisms and motivations are very good! However, his flaws and prejudices kind of show a larger problem with your character. He's a bit too perfect. It'll be hard for readers to connect with someone that kind and considerate, whose biggest flaw is his "not being able to make plans." Readers want to see a character struggle both externally and internally. If he has no negative traits or beliefs whatsoever, his internal conflict will be nonexistent and he'll become a boring character. For his flaws, add a few genuinely negative traits, or explain how the flaws he has are actual conflicts that he actively needs to work on overcoming. For his prejudice, include a preconceived belief that is most definitely not true or irrational. Maybe he hates an entire race of people. Maybe he's subconsciously sexist or ableist because he doesn't think his sister can do anything on her own. Just…don't be afraid to make your character human! Other than that, very well done on this section, especially his personality type.

…yeah, that's really all I've got. Great job developing Tanis. I really see a hell of a lot of potential in his character. Well done!

@WriteOutofTime

Hey, could you look at my character? Gabrielle Strasser
By the way, the story I'm writing has several narrators that end up in the story itself. It's a bit complicated, but Gabrielle is one of the narrators.

Hi there! I am back from my hiatus and ready to review your character! Here we go:

Looks
5'8 is quite tall for a 13-year-old. If that was on purpose, ignore that. However, she is incredibly underweight for her height. At 5'7, I weigh…ahem…quite a bit more than that, and I'm only kinda chubby. But my sister, who is an inch taller than me, is very skinny and she's in the 120-130lbs range. 126-154lbs are the average weights for someone of that height. Just something to think about.

Nature
Only one mannerisms? One, almost universal mannerism? Come on! Somewhere in this thread I listed quite a few unique mannerisms, so feel free to borrow a few if you'd like. What does Gabrielle do when she's mad? How does she smile? What does her face/body/hands do when she's embarrassed or nervous? When she laughs? Her motivation doesn't seem very personal, but since I'm not familiar with the story, I'm not sure. Why does she want to destroy the necklaces? How is it personal for her? What does she want more than anything? Her flaws are pretty good. Talents and hobbies are a bit basic, but not bad. Her personality type is… three words? That seems odd. What is she like? What is her personality? How does she act around strangers vs friends vs family? Is she outgoing, friendly? Shy, awkward? Funny?

Social
Err…where is the social section? I recommend filling it out. It's hard to critique a character with so little information…

History
No background either, huh?

Overall…well, it seems like you don't know your character very well. Sit down and get to know her! Think about her background and how it reflects in her current attitude and personality. Consider all facets of her personality and write it down. No detail is too small. It really helps when you're writing to genuinely know your character. Good luck.

@WriteOutofTime

Can you critique this character for me? Invalid Character thanks!

Hello! Thanks for being patient. Here is your critique:

Nature
Ooh, great mannerisms. Her motivation seems quite consistent with her character, but I feel you could add more. What does she want more than anything? What is it about friendship that motivates her? Does she crave deeper connection because she no longer has that connection with her sister, or more social interaction? Is she lonely, or just friendly? Her flaws are very good. I feel that she could use a few talents unconnected with the story. Is she good at anything else? For example, making friends or connecting with others? Her hobbies are pretty good and so is her personality type.

Social
For her religion, you say she doubts that there is a god. Does that mean she wonders whether or not there is one, or is she pretty convinced there isn't one? Her beliefs might align more closely with Agnostic than Atheist, but I'm not sure. Just something to consider. Is there a story behind why a handaxe is her favorite weapon? Or is it her favorite just because it's cool?

History
I love her background! But what do you mean she was self taught? Did she not go to school? Super-smartness can only go so far, or else it starts to feel horribly unrealistic. What type of intelligence does she have? Does she excel in certain subjects more than others?

Overall, quite a solid character. Good job.

@Kinarymo

@writelikeyourerunningoutoftime thanks for the reply and for pointing out the problems. For some reason, my mind took a nap while i was trying to come up with more information, but i'll make sure to complete it eventually. I'm glad you consider Tanis a good character, as i was heavily unsure if he was good enough to be a realistic character, let alone a protagonist (character developing issues). Thanks a lot, it really helped!
Also, would you mind if i asked for another critique? I had finished this character some time ago and i was really curious to know if he is good enough
Here he is - Tierlan
Again, thank you so much

@WriteOutofTime

Would you mind taking a look at this character of mine? I'd love to hear your critiques on him! Invalid Character

Hello! First of all, is the art yours?? It's incredible! I love his character design so much. Okay, anyway, on to the critique!

Looks
As I said, his design is super cute. I am curious about one thing, though. What are his horns for? Do they have a purpose beyond the aesthetic? It seems rather pointless to include a detail like that without more explanation.

Nature
Good job on his mannerisms! It wouldn't hurt to add a few more, though. For example, what does his body/face/hands do when he laughs? When he cries? When he's bored/absent minded? I like his motivations, but since he is the main character, I actually think you need to simplify it down a little. Or, well, simplify isn't the right word for it. Give him a clear direction. All of his motivations should lead towards one common goal. What does he want more than anything? And why does he want it? The motivation serves as the hero's call to action –the reason why he fights/exists/is the main character. Okay, on to his flaws. I really like them, but I feel you could expound on them a bit more. For example, you say that he lies to people to make them feel better, instead of giving them the truth. Take that a step further. Is he a pushover? Does he agree with everyone/everything for the sake of simplicity? Is he compromising? Orrr, is he manipulative to the point that he lies for his own personal gain? Etc. His talents and hobbies are alright. His personality type could be a little more in-depth. How does he act around strangers vs friends vs family? Is he shy? What does it take to make him angry? To make him cry? What's his sense of humor like?

Social
No religion or politics? I strongly recommend including those two categories. They provide valuable insight into your character's mindset, even if they're atheist and avoid politics like the plague. Just writing down their views on important/universal problems like religion or politics is quite helpful in understanding their mind. Also, no favorite possession? Any particular reason why he doesn't have one?

Notes Which Serve the Same Purpose as The History Section
Nice backstory! A lot of details, which is good. Yeah, no complaints here. Thanks for the interesting read.

Overall, definitely a strong base for a character. Caprah has a lot of potential. Good luck!

@WriteOutofTime

Could you critique my guy?

Let me know if you have questions

First let me say how happy I am to be critiquing an antagonist! Especially such a well thought out and well balanced one –Timour reminds me a lot of one of the antagonists in a story I'm currently writing. Hopefully I'll be able to give you an unbiased critique…here we go:

Nature
Alright, as much as I adoRE the little bits of backstory you entwined in the mannerism section, you've actually only listed one mannerism. I don't critique many animal characters, so I'm not really familiar with what type of mannerisms a wolf would do…that being said, I assume body language will be a big thing. So, what does his tail do with different emotions? Does his fur bristle/stand on end? What does he do when he's nervous? Does he try to hide it? How? His motivations are great! Very believable, especially for an antagonist. His flaws are good, but kind of one-track. Arrogance and pride are very similar and thusly hardly separable. Add a few more flaws. Is he narrow-minded? Selfish? Cold? His prejudice is good. His hobbies and talents are purely plot related. I suggest adding in a few more that aren't necessarily important to the narrative. Just to help humanize him and make him relatable. What does he do in his spare time? What does he do for fun? Does he have something that he's surprisingly good at? His personality type is good!

Social
No religion? Is religion not a thing among the wolves in your story? If it is, be sure to include it for Timour. Religion is a great way to understand a character at a deeper level. As for his politics, I'm thinking he might be a bit more fascist than conservative? Since he wants to get rid of those with "weaker" blood… that seems drastic for conservative viewpoints. Fascism might not be 100% the word for it, but I don't think conservative fits.

History
Slow clapping Great job.

Overall, what a solid character! Timour seems well-developed and well thought out, especially for an antagonist. Just don't fall into too many cliches, and I think you're good. Good job and good luck :D