So, I’m writing a story based off of four songs and characters that you can see in this thread: https://www.notebook.ai/forum/characters-board/so-i-have-an-idea
I’m combining fan theories surrounding these songs with my own ideas. This is part one of the story, and I’ll start working on part two soon. Enjoy!
Part I: The Conflicts of the Heart, Mind, and Soul
“You don’t understand. . .”
“No. You don’t understand. Why can’t you get it?”
“Get what?”
“You’re useless. Too emotional, too weak. Your weakness is exactly what will get us killed.”
“I’m not. . .”
“This constant little pity party of yours affects the rest of us, you know. It affects the Whole.”
“It’s not like you don’t feel anything! Constantly ranting and raving about my uselessness to Soul!”
“Would you rather me tell you up front?”
“Maybe I would. Maybe I would like you to tell me instead of being such a coward—“
“I am not a coward.”
“Ow-“
“Would you like to try that again, Heart? Maybe think before you speak this time.”
“If you want me to think, maybe don’t shove me against the wall when I’m just trying to make a point.”
“Then I would suggest you keep your mouth shut.”
——
Heart ran their fingers through their hair, loosely holding their blindfold in their other hand. Their void-like eyes drooped, and tears stained their cheeks. Soul had found out about their argument with Mind, and they were both scolded, which Heart of course didn’t do well with. Now they sat alone in a dark corner, seething. It was so unfair. Mind just didn’t get it, he didn’t get that Heart wasn’t useless. The Whole needed Heart’s emotion to survive. . . Right?
What are you doing?
A list of adjectives repeated itself in their head. Shallow, cold, wretched, miserable, dark. . . That was all they could think of, was how awful Mind was.
Put the gun down.
Maybe Mind was the useless one. Soul was logical enough, surely the Whole didn’t need a cynical, indifferent part to work, did it? Maybe. . . just maybe, if Mind was gone, the Whole would work better, and Soul wouldn’t be so mad anymore.
Think about this.
Heart shook their head. No, that would be terrible. They couldn’t kill Mind.
. . .
But it certainly wasn’t out of the question.
——
“Heart?”
“Yes. . ?”
“Why are you sitting in the dark?
“The light hurts my eyes.”
“Isn’t that what your blindfold is for?”
“I can’t wear that all the time. It gets uncomfortable.”
“Right. . . hey, I’m sorry about yelling at you earlier.”
“Hm? Oh, it’s fine.”
“I’m not trying to upset you. Mind does enough of that already. But you know how much I need you and Mind to get along.”
“I know.”
“Without us all working together, Whole’s in a really bad state.”
“I know. . .”
“Okay, okay. I’ll. . . try to talk to Mind. I know he usually starts these fights.”
“Thank you.”
——
Mind paced in a uniform pattern, like he always did when he needed to cool off. Back, forth. Back, forth. He had his arms crossed, and just stared straight ahead, dead-faced as usual. Heart was being. . . unusually aggressive lately. Or maybe bold was the right word. He didn’t appreciate their petty insults, claiming that they were ‘just making a point.’ They knew exactly what they were doing.
Useless. Weak. That creature hardly resembled a man. Mind didn’t see Soul’s reason for keeping Heart around, let alone forcing him to get along with them. He simply stated fact, and he saw no reason for Heart to get angry. And yet, Heart still wanted to hear his thoughts, despite being hurt by them. They were… confusing to say the least.
He was getting increasingly more annoyed as Soul approached him. He must have talked to Heart already. Heart, who was probably crying in their dark little corner. Mind sighed, stopped pacing, then turned to face Soul.
——
“Mind.”
“Soul.”
“I’ll assume you already know what I’m here about, then.”
“When do I not know?”
“Fair enough.”
“Just get this over with.”
“Mind, you know you and Heart need to get along. You know better than to say things that hurt their feelings.”
“I’m just saying what I think.”
“Sometimes thoughts should be kept to ourselves. I have several things I’d like to say about you, but do I say them?”
“Not that I’m aware of.”
“Exactly. Because you tend to resort to violence when you’re angry.”
“No, I- . . . Okay. Fine.”
“We all need to be present for Whole to work. And we also need to get along. Got it?”
“I get it every time you say it.”
“Clearly, you don’t. Just. . . stay away from Heart for a bit. You both need to calm down.”
——
Soul sighed. He just wished that Mind and Heart could work together for a few minutes, at least. The Whole was getting. . . extremely erratic. Violent, even. He wasn’t sure how much longer Whole would last, if the others kept fighting. And the fighting was getting worse, too. Mind didn’t stop at verbal abuse anymore, and Soul could tell that Heart was getting fed up. There was no telling what would happen next.
All Soul could do was try to stabilize Whole, before it was too late for them all. He had to succeed, or he would die trying. They all would.
——
Bad idea.
Killing is wrong.
But I have to. How else will this end?
We won’t get along.
We can’t.
I have to kill him.
Seethe, as they snarl at you.
No more pain.
Watch them struggle just to stand.
No more anger. . .
The weaker half of man.
Everyone would be happier.
Watch them beg and bargain, time and time again.
Right. . ?
Right??
——
Mind stood with his back facing Heart.
He knew Heart was there, of course. But he sensed that he shouldn’t say so, not yet.
Heart was stalking towards Mind.
They didn’t know that Mind was completely aware of Heart’s presence. They thought they were doing a good job of sneaking up on Mind. They left their blindfold hanging loosely around their neck, so they could pull it back up after the job was done.
The gun felt cold and heavy in Heart’s hand. They weren’t used to holding any sort of weapon. Usually, they kept their intrusive thoughts as just that: a thought. But this was an idea, not a thought. And they were in too deep now.
Mind felt tense. He knew that something bad was about to happen. Heart was stalking closer, like they were about to attack them. He opened his mouth to speak, but his breath caught in his throat.
Click. A gun pressed against the back of his head. He clenched his jaw.
“What do you think you’re doing, Heart?”
“Don’t. Move.”
Their voice shook. Their hands trembled. Just shoot. Pull the trigger. Just do it—
“Put the gun down.”
“No.”
“Think about what you’re going to do.”
“No—“
Before Heart could do anything, Mind swiftly turned and grabbed Heart’s wrist, yanking it upward to aim the gun away from him. Heart pulled the trigger a second too late, shooting a bullet harmlessly into the ceiling.
Heart yelped as Mind then threw them to the ground. They kept a tight hold on the gun, pointing it at Mind as they tried to scramble to their feet. They shot again as Mind lunged for them.
Mind growled as pain shot through his shoulder, but that didn’t stop him from tackling Heart to the ground. The gun clattered as it fell from Heart’s grasp. Mind grabbed Heart by the throat as they struggled, ignoring the throbbing in his shoulder.
Heart’s scream died in their throat, cut off as Mind strangled them. Silent tears spilled from their eyes, and they clawed hopelessly at Mind’s hand, struggling for breath.
“What the hell is going on here?!”
Soul.
——
“They fucking shot me, that’s what happened!”
“Get off of them, Mind.”
“No! Just let me-“
“What the fuck did I just say?”
“We don’t need them, anyway! Do you really expect me to just let them kill me?”
“No one is killing anyone.”
“But-“
“MIND.”
“. . .”
“Get. Off.”
“Fine.”
. . .
. . .
“. . . Heart? Are you with me?”
——
Heart drew in a deep, shaky breath. They blinked a few times, trying to clear the dark spots from their vision. Their throat throbbed, and every breath made it worse. They hardly noticed when Soul helped them up, until they were in a sitting position, with Soul firmly grasping their shoulders.
They looked up at Soul. They didn’t see anything in his expression aside from. . . disappointment. Anger would have been better, they thought. They averted their gaze.
“What in the world were you thinking, Heart?”
Heart didn’t answer at first. Truthfully, they didn’t even know anymore. Their original motive now seemed childish and petty. They shut their eyes tightly.
“Heart?”
“I. . . I don’t know.”
“There has to be a reason. Why did you shoot Mind?”
More silence. Heart sighed.
“I thought. . . I thought if Mind was gone, things would be better off. You’re logical enough. You can do. . . the smart things. All he does is push me around, and yell, and complain. I. . . I thought that the Whole would be better.”
Soul didn’t answer.
“I’m sorry.”
“Sorry doesn’t fix bullet holes and crushed windpipes.”
Heart subconsciously moved a hand to their throat. They made a mistake. A really, really terrible mistake.
“Just. . . go let yourself heal. I’ll talk to you and Mind tomorrow. Right now I need to fix the mess you two just made.”
——
“You understand why I want to talk to you two?”
“Yes.”
“Mhm. . .”
“Heart, try to save your voice.”
“Okay.”
“That fight of yours screwed us over. The Whole has been unstable and violent the entire time you two have been struggling to get along, and I’ve been the only one to stabilize him.”
“I don’t see how this is new.”
“Oh, this isn’t new. I’ve been trying for far too long to stabilize both the Whole and you two, but it’s just not working. I think it’s safe to assume that you don’t really care about our wellbeing.”
“Soul . . ? What do you mean?”
“I’m done.”
“What?”
“What do you mean, you’re ‘done’? That’s not how this works.”
“You think you get to decide how things work around here? You forget you answer to me. I decide how things work around here, Mind.”
“You can’t just-“
“I can do whatever I feel is necessary.”
“I’m scared. . .”
“Yeah? Well, you should have thought about the consequences before you tried to kill Mind.”
“. . .”
“I can’t stabilize things for much longer. I’ve decided to shut things down for good. It looks like you’re wishes have been granted.”
“What do you mean-?”
“I think we know exactly what he means, Heart.”
“You do. The Whole is going to die, and us with it.”
“What?! No! You can’t—“
“Heart, shut up. Arguing is pointless now.”
“But. . .”
“Again, you both should have thought about the consequences of your actions. But you didn’t. I hope you’re happy with yourselves.”
——