forum I Can Help Edit Scenes, Characters, and Much More!
Started by Deleted user
tune
Edit topic

people_alt 7 followers

Deleted user

Hello! For some reason my account won't let me open my last critique chat, so I'm opening up a new one. This is just what the title says! If you need help with some grammar or a blurb, please feel free to ask for help. I won't be doing full books, but shorter chapters are most likely fine. Oh, and if you want me to do characters than please post the details in this chat if you can. I can click on links, but it's a lot easier for me to just comment with it in front of me.
To summarize, here's a list of what I will do:

  • Discuss characters (appearances, hobbies, thoughts, etc.)
  • Help with plots (summarized, please)
  • Find names for any genre
  • Edit or read poetry (or stanzas)
  • Read and suggest changes for scenes
  • Answer questions to the best of my ability (with research!)
  • Help describe settings
  • Keep you on schedule with possible reminders ;)
    If you need anything else that's not listed, just ask and I'll tell you if I can do anything about it. Please join the conversation if you're interested! I'd like to keep this relatively contained, so please don't leave too many short messages like, "Oh, k. Thanks."

Deleted user

Oh, I forgot to mention a few other things. I will do any genre except for fanfics, straight up porn/smut/etc., and nonfiction novels. If you have any intimate scenes you want me to read, I can do them, but please be aware that it cannot be too graphic or descriptive. I want to keep this chat at least PG13 for anyone who feels uncomfortable around that sort of thing. I will also read violent scenes, but the same rules apply. Please be respectful to everyone around you when commenting.
A few other things I can check for:

  • Mary/Gary Sues (basically overpowered, overly dramatic, or cringeworthy characters)
  • Switching tenses or other things that seem out of place
  • Unfair and unrealistic fight scenes
  • Random and unnecessary details
  • Unnatural dialoge
    Now, that should be mostly everything. Let's hope this chat works this time.

Krynn

Do you mind if the story is decently long? Or do you have a limit to how much you're willing to edit?

@Reblod flag

Could you help with this? So I have this prophecy type thing…I guess you could call it a prophecy. I wanted it to sound like it could be a prophecy but not too prophetic-like. Thoughts?

Letting of blood
Feeding of earth
To war, to war
Chaos, calamity
The rogues of war
Letting of blood
Feeding of earth
No hope, no hope
Despair, hunger
Our thieves of hope
Letting of blood
Feeding of earth
It burns, it burns
Pain, suffering
Our heart of fire
Letting of blood
Feeding of earth
The madness, the madness
Cold, frost
The madness of ice rain

It has the four titles of the four parts (books if they were to become books) of this story. (The) Rogues of War, (Our) Thieves of Hope, (Our) Heart of Fire, (The) Madness of Ice Rain. This doesn't represent the whole story but it's important.

@LittleBear group

So I have already had this critiqued but I am always looking for more perspectives, beware it is a little long:

Aelina

Her dark curls shone even here in the dim lamplight of the outer district. It baffled me how even now her features could be this stunning and it somehow justified my plan. No one could be that perfect–suspiciously perfect. We rounded the corner and the street, now little more than a rocky alley way took a turn for the worse. Grime crept down the brick walls of buildings and debris littered the ground. In the distance I could hear the yowls of fighting cats and screech of black birds.

She did not even seem to notice the sudden change in scenery. Natiselle continued to titter on about some gown she had seen at the dressmaker’s and how it was so unfair that her color choices were so limited by the Pravaci Court. She was utterly unconcerned that we were steadily approaching some of the worst parts of the city.

Then, as if on cue, a dark figure stepped out of the shadows. “Two pretty ladies. Bless Archanie. Looks like a win tonight, eh lads?” I turned around and saw two more ruffians behind us. Something was terribly wrong. It was only supposed to be Jatil; he had assured me that he would do it himself. The man in front of us was decidedly not Jatil, he was much too tall. The bottom of my stomach fell and my hands began to shake, the full weight of my mistake dawned on me.

Natiselle took a step forward and looked the man up and down. I wanted nothing more than to yell at her for being a fool but my voice seemed to have deserted me

“Now, what would you lovely gentlemen want with us?” She played with the ribbon at the front of her dress as she moved. “Surely it would be more prudent for you to escort us to our destination and be rewarded handsomely upon our arrival.” She dared to flutter her eyelashes at them. “Our purses are much too meager to satisfy the three of you.”

“Hear that? We’re gentlemen now,” the stout one snickered.

“She speaks such pretty words, but oh how stupid,” the leader leered. They started to circle us, like predator around prey, like the hyenas from my books. “You see lovely, a nice clean toss is so hard to find in the out parts. There is so much more than your purse to be had.”

“I don’t think I’ve seen such a delicate lady in my life,” the thin one panted.

The leader cocked his head and looked at Natiselle, “What do you think lads, I think darkie over here can take two of us.”

“I don’t care as long as I get blondie.”

The air seemed to shift, like a cloak falling away, revealing the world as it truly was. I looked at Natiselle and gone was the frivolous girl who cared only about her jewels, in her stead was a steely eyed creature with a lip curling in rage. “Wrong thing to say, ‘lads’,” disgust dripped from her voice, a full octave lower than normal. She pulled at the ribbon she had been fiddling with and her skirt and petticoats fell away, revealing tightfitting trousers and flat soled boots. Somehow she had managed to secure two forearm length blades and a whip to her thighs. “I can take all three of you.”

My skin crawled as if the claw of death had trailed down the length of my spine. I could hear the blood rushing to my ears, a throbbing beat like war drums that drowned out everything else. She strung into action and if I had not been too terrified to move, I would have shielded my eyes. With a flick the whip wrapped itself around the main thug’s neck and his eyes bugged as he clawed at his neck. The stocky one ran at her and she nimbly slid out of the way, turning and pulling at her whip in the same motion. He missed her and as he ran past kicked out the back of his knee and sent him sprawling.

“Natiselle, behind you!” I yelped as the last remaining ruffian approached her back, knife in hand. She turned at the last moment and drew one of her blades. She blocked him with her forearm and ducked under his swipe. Figuring that she needed both hands, she let go of the whip and threw the blade at the leader. It found its mark in his stomach and he looked down in shock. With a yank he pulled it out and immediately blood bloomed across his shirt. I could feel the bile rising in my throat.

She did not even pause. Natiselle had pulled her remaining blade and was ducking and weaving around each swipe he tried to land. She danced around him, slicing at any opening–his back, side, cheek. Every cut she landed caused him to roar with pain or anger.

Suddenly, I could feel a grimy hand at my throat, pulling me to him. The stocky one that had fallen, I had forgotten about him. I could feel his hot breath on my head, smelling of rot and his last meal. His sweaty shirt clung to my back and I could almost feel it through my bodice. A gasp escaped me and Natiselle’s face whipped to me. Her eyes narrowed as spots danced in my vision and she raised her hand and her dagger flew through the air. Space seemed to hang still as it came towards us. My knees buckled and only his hand was keeping upright. Then I could feel wetness in my hair and on my forehead. His grip fell away and air flooded my lungs.

I turned to look at him and saw the hilt protruding from his thick neck. My stomach heaved and I fell to all fours. The gravel bit into my palms, but the stable ground comforted me. I lifted my head and saw Natiselle behind the last one, her elbow in line with his jaw and her legs wrapped around his waist. She was clutching on of her fists and looked to be pulling up with all her might, her teeth gritted in the effort. Her lips were moving, almost as if she was counting. He clawed at her arm for a moment before pitching forward.

She did not let go for what seemed like an eternity. Finally she rolled off of him, her heaving breath the only sound in the night. She stumbled to her feet, cleaned her hands on her now filthy trousers, and started to retrieve her weapons. I watched as she wiped the blood from her blades on each victim’s clothes before sheathing them again.

“How –” I started, “How did you do that? You met your mark every time.” She looked at me and I realized my mouth must have been agape. I dragged my sleeve across it in an effort to remove the bile.

“I was aiming for their foreheads,” she said, her face flushed but otherwise emotionless. Her eyes narrowed and my heart sank as if I knew what the next words out of her mouth would be. “You knew this was going to happen did you not? This is why you brought me here.” Her voice was so quiet and fear shot through me. “There is no ‘delicious dining hall’ in this region is there?”

“I – I did not expect for this–” I stumbled over my words, “my friend was –”

“To what? Jump out and scare me?”

“I, yes, but –”

“Why?” she spat.

“I was jealous.” It was not until the words left my mouth that I realized my true motivation. The look in her eyes seemed to turn from murder to something like pity. To my surprise she offered me a hand. “Are you not going to kill me?”

“Why? Are you trying to kill me? She asked, a singular eyebrow quirking up.

“No.”

“Then why in three hells would I kill you?” she cursed.

“I know that you are not what you seem. You are more than just some lord’s daughter, here to find a wealthy husband.” Finally my voice seemed to find its footing.

“You owe me now, three times over. You are too useful to dispose of now,” she said, “and I am not an animal. I would never kill an unarmed man or woman. Are you going to stay on the ground in your own filth or not?”
I took her hand and she pulled me to my feet. She collected her skirt and refastened it to her waist, but not before I noticed the cuts on her arms and legs. “I am so sorry. You are hurt!” I exclaimed.
She turned to look at herself. “Hmm, so I am.” Natiselle looked down at her skirt and swore at the now stained mess they were in. “I want my clothes mended and laundered by Wednesday.” I nodded vigorously. Satisfied, she started back the way we came.

A puff of air escaped me and I was overcome with relief. As the adrenaline left me, exhaustion took its place. I followed after her, trying by best to keep my fatigue at bay. After a while, we made it back to a main street. “Let me see your house gem.” She thrust her hand at me and without a word I pulled the ruby from its place next to my heart. She closed her hand around the golden chain and said, “Follow my lead.” She stumbled toward an approaching carriage, her fist outstretched with the ruby swinging and glittering in the lamplight. I did not need to pretend to be tired, my legs felt like lead.

“Help!” She cried, managing to be both breathless and loud. We must have been a sight, Natiselle with her tattered and bloody sleeves and me with bile and blood in my hair.
The carriage slowed and the alarmed lord and lady peered out. “Please, we beg your help to the Pravaci District.” The lady looked at her husband and put a gentile hand on his arm. “House Toulerin will reward you greatly”. He nodded and the door swung open. I sunk into the cushions gratefully and promptly fainted.

@WriteOutofTime

Critique this?

Morning came with pain. The streetlights outside her window had changed from the cold lighting of the night to the warmth of the artificial UV rays. There was peace outside her home, but she could practically hear the riots that were sure to be going on by now.
Nyir felt vaguely disappointed. Sleep didn’t cure her tiredness, nor did it cure her soreness. Her eyes felt warm and heavy, like marbles trying to roll through honey. She cursed every breath she took.

“Damn it,” she moaned, shoving herself upright. The sheets fell from her bruised body and gathered around her hips. They were tinted with blood, and she cursed again. Had she torn her stitches?

She ran her fingers down her exposed scalp and down into her cornrows. The motion was soothing. She repeated it, taking deep breaths, until she felt almost normal. The rattling in her lungs had quieted to a soft wheeze, and the pain, a dull ache. Her free hand felt underneath her shirt, tearing off the damp bandages and tracing the stitches. Yeah, torn. She’d never been a heavy sleeper. Her restlessness must have torn them.

“I’m alive,” she breathed. The statement was neutral.

Enough about her, she decided. She thought back over the night before –Evera, and everything she’d said. She wondered if Evera had arrested the kid anyway, but decided against it. She’d seemed set against it, and Evera wasn’t one to change her mind easily. The Northern kid was safe, for now. But would that last?

Her eyes trailed over to the side table again. Yuu’mi had been from the North. Near the tunnels. He’d been outspoken about it. Nyir hadn’t care much about what he’d been saying, but now, things were different. If he wasn’t the one speaking up, then who would? Nyir would not let his voice be forgotten. But usually, his beliefs were an afterthought. She was too busy.

Shaking those thoughts away impatiently, she forced herself to her feet. Dizziness nearly dragged her back down as the blood rushed from her head. She managed to stay upright as she made her way to the kitchen, keeping a hold to the walls and furniture to support her as she went.

Tasper was already sat at the table, with Daso at his side. They were gathered around the radio with mugs of tea, listening to static. When Daso spotted her, he rose to his feet, greeting, “Hi, General! Feeling better, darling?”

“Nope,” she replied with a tight smile. “Why’re you in my house?” She sank into the chair across from him and to the right of Tasper. Tasper poured her a cup of tea absently, his eyes still on the radio.

Daso sat back down as well. “Evera sent me. She wanted your permission to employ your regiment to help control the crowd. She’s about to announce a meeting.” He gestured to the radio.

“Clearance granted,” she responded with a half shrug. She lifted her mug to her lips.

Tasper glanced away from the radio to ask, “Can I tag along, Daso? I’m curious.”

“Sure, kid,” he answered with a smile, “and we’ll swing by to pick up Sacia. No one should travel alone with all this chaos, not even a daring doll like her.”

At that, Tas lowered his head. Nyir could see him thinking. She wished sometimes that he wasn’t so easy to read. “You fought with Sacia again?”

“Not really,” he replied, a little too fast, “I just…I brought up stuff I shouldn’t’ve. The real problem is the way she treated Mitsig.”

Nyir shrugged. “Sure.” She prepared herself to say more, but the static on the radio changed to a loud voice.

“Attention all Lower World residents: This is Leader Evera. There have been rumors about missing rations, and I must set them straight. Please make your way to the Platform near the stables by 0900 to receive more information. Please trust that you are safe, and the Board is doing everything it can to keep you that way. Again, a meeting at the Platform near the stables at 0900. Thank you.”

The message started over. Nyir shut the radio off and looked at the clock on the wall. The meeting wasn’t for another hour or so. She sighed, “You two go on and get there before the crowd. It’ll be hell trying to get there at the same time as everyone.”

“Trying to get rid of us so soon?” Daso shot back with a grin, already standing and pushing the chair back underneath the table.

Tasper finished his tea in one gulp and scrambled to his feet. “Yeah, good idea. I’ll be ready in a moment.” He hurried into the back of the house, disappearing into his room.

“I think Eve’s in over her head,” Daso blurted out the moment Tasper was out of earshot, his smile fading.

Nyir didn’t reply for a long moment, inspecting the shining black liquid in her cup. Finally, she said, “Don’t wait ‘til Tasper’s gone to speak your mind. You’re a kid too.” She sipped her tea.

Daso’s grin flew back onto his face, but she could see in his eyes that he was hurt. He leaned against the wall, his lips puckering. “I’m nearly eighteen, you know!” he joked, standing up on his tiptoes.

“What I meant,” she said, lowering her mug, “was that I won’t hold things back from you or him or anyone unless I want. It’s never because of your age.”

He nodded. “I know. I know.” A wry smirk appeared on his youthful face. “By the way, Dara got a promotion, thanks to us.”

“How do you mean?” Nyir queried, lifting an eyebrow.

“The sample we collected.” He smiled, linking his fingers behind his head. “She’s got a theory and she’s going to be running the experiments herself. Leader Simanta herself gave her fifth level clearance.”

She nodded her head, unsurprised. “She was always the better twin out of the two of you.”

“She’s the smart one, I’m the pretty one,” he corrected, snickering. “Anyway, she feels like she’s close to a breakthrough. She wanted to let you know that.”

Nyir shrugged. “They always are.”

“No, this time’s…different.” A rare serious look spread over his countenance. “She thinks she has a way to really hurt them, maybe even kill them.”

Her hand tightened around her mug, but she purposefully kept her expression calm. Despite herself, her heart rate began to speed up. In a daze, she repeated, “Kill them?”

“Theoretically,” Daso clarified. His face relaxed back into his usual smile, and he laughed, “So, no need to go off on suicide missions anymore, yeah?”

Nyir nodded again, her hand relaxing as well. “Sounds promising. I’ll visit her lab as soon as I’m able.”

They didn’t speak anymore. Tasper returned to the front and he and Daso left, mumbling quick goodbyes. She watched them with a passive eye, her thoughts tumultuous. Her jaw clenched.

A way to kill dragons. She wished she could believe it.

Deleted user

Hey, everyone! I'm gonna go in order. Sorry this took so long- only one of my computers can access this site. I'll try to be a little quicker next time!

Deleted user

@Krynn
It has to be a reasonable length. I don't want to do a full book, but I'd be fine with up to two chapters if they're not more than 10,000 words combined.

Krynn

Okay, thanks! When you're done critiquing everybody else's I'll post mine, that way you're not too overwhelmed!

Deleted user

@Reblod
I like the thought behind the title names being in the actual prophecy. It's a really neat concept that I think a lot of people typically ignore when they're trying to make these types of things rhyme. Clever thinking on your part!
Now, for the actual critique part of it:
Everything, except for one thing I'll cover in a bit, was good! I really liked the repetition of the two phrases, and I liked how you kept a pattern going throughout the whole thing. At first, I was a little concerned that it didn't make sense, but after reading it again I understand the concept behind it and enjoy how you transitioned using words related to the theme of the titles.
The thing I would suggest is about the last part is about the choice of using "ice rain". I get that it's your title, but wouldn't it make more sense if it was 'The Madness of Icy Rain'? Or, if you wanted to get into weather terms, 'The Madness of Freezing Rain'? All of the other titles are pretty great, but this one struck me as a bit oddly worded.
Hope this was helpful! I'd give more edits if I had any, but I honestly don't see anything else off with it.

Deleted user

@LittleBear
No need to worry! I definitely expected some lengthy chapters or blurbs when I made this chat, and yours isn't that bad. Anything less than 10,000 words is fine with me!
The only thing with these longer critiques is that there's probably going to be a bit more nitpicking and corrections than usual. Hope that's fine with you!
Let's get started! If I didn't make any corrections for any exact sentence in a paragraph, it's because I didn't think it needed it.

Paragraph 1:

  • "… shone even here…"
    I don't think you need the even there, especially since you use it again in the next part. I don't think you need the here, either. You might consider: "Her dark curls shone in the dim…"
  • "… could be this stunning and it somehow…"
    Comma after stunning!
  • "… that perfect–suspiciously perfect."
    I think you could just make it "… that suspiciously perfect." The repetition sounds a bit strange here.
  • "We rounded the corner and the street, now little more than a rocky alley way took a turn for the worse."
    The fact that you don't have a sort of transition after the comma made me a little confused about the sentence. Also, I believe the part about it taking a turn for the worse might need a bit of rephrasing. I think it'd make a bit more sense if you made it "… street, which was now little more than a rocky alley that had, at some point, taken a turn for the worse." Or something along those lines, anyway.

Paragraph 2:

  • "(the whole paragraph)"
    If I were you, I'd switch her name to the first sentence and make the second one fitted a little more with the third. The only reason I'd do this is so the first sentence doesn't sound like too much of a continuation of the first paragraph. Here's what it might turn out as:
    "Natiselle did not even seem to notice the sudden change in scenery. She continued to titter on about some gown she had seen at the dressmaker's, unconcerned that we were steadily approaching some of the worst parts of the city, and how unfair it was that her color choices were so limited by the Pravaci Court."
    Maybe not exactly that, but I think you get the point.

Paragraph 3:

  • " The man in front of us was decidedly not Jatil, he was much too tall."
    I'd suggest either making it "… not Jatil, for he was…" or just "… not Jatil. He was…" because otherwise I'm not sure if it makes complete grammatical sense.
  • "The bottom of my stomach fell and my hands began to shake, the full weight of my mistake dawned on me."
    Take out the comma after shake and add an 'as'. For example: "… began to shake as the full weight of my…"

Paragraph 4:

  • "I wanted nothing more than to yell at her for being a fool but my voice seemed to have deserted me."
    I'm not 100% sure on this, but I believe there needs to be a comma before the but. I think that makes sense.

Paragraph 7:

  • " 'She speaks such pretty words, but oh how stupid,” the leader leered. They started to circle us, like predator around prey, like the hyenas from my books. “You see lovely, a nice clean toss is so hard to find in the out parts. There is so much more than your purse to be had.' "
    I'd make it "… but oh, how stupid…" just to add a bit more emphasis, then go on and take out one of the 'like's. Maybe change that to "They started to circle us, practically predator around prey, like the hyenas from my books."

Paragraph 9:

  • "The leader cocked his head and looked at Natiselle, 'What do you think lads, I think darkie over here can take two of us.' "
    The comma after Natiselle should be a period, and you might consider "What do you think, lads?" for the second part.

Paragraph 11:

  • "The air seemed to shift, like a cloak falling away, revealing the world as it truly was."
    I don't believe you need the comma after shift.
  • "I looked at Natiselle and gone was the frivolous girl who cared only about her jewels, in her stead was a steely eyed creature with a lip curling in rage."
    To make it flow better, I would put a period after jewels and capitalize the next word to make that a complete sentence. For example: "… her jewels. In her stead was a steely-eyed creature with a lip curled in rage."
  • " 'Wrong thing to say, ‘lads’,' disgust dripped from her voice, a full octave lower than normal. She pulled at the ribbon she had been fiddling with and her skirt and petticoats fell away, revealing tightfitting trousers and flat soled boots. Somehow she had managed to secure two forearm length blades and a whip to her thighs. 'I can take all three of you.'"
    I would actually make this part into your next paragraph. So, technically this would be part of paragraph 12, but I'll keep it here for the convenience.
    You should take out the comma after 'lads' and make it a period, then capitalize disgust. Maybe even put a 'which was' between the comma after voice and the letter a.
    You also probably need a comma after the 'with' in the next sentence. Also, I think it should be flat-soled boots.
    The next sentence should be fine.

Paragraph 12:

  • "She strung into action and if I had not been too terrified to move, I would have shielded my eyes."
    I think strung should be sprung, and I believe you need a comma before the and.
  • "With a flick the whip wrapped itself around the main thug’s neck and his eyes bugged as he clawed at his neck."
    You definitely don't need to use neck twice in the same sentence. Maybe try "With a flick the whip wrapped itself around the main thug's neck. His eyes bugged as he clawed at it desperately."
  • "He missed her and as he ran past kicked out the back of his knee and sent him sprawling."
    This is a bit of a winding sentence. I'd suggest something a little more simple to fit in with the action of the rest of the paragraph, like "He missed her. As he ran past, she kicked out the back of his knee, sending him sprawling." That's not exactly what you should do, but I think it's pretty close.

Paragraph 13:

  • "She turned at the last moment and drew one of her blades. She blocked him with her forearm and ducked under his swipe."
    If you want, you can combine this to make a more cohesive thought. "She turned at the last moment, quickly drew one of her blades, blocked him with her forearm, and then ducked under his next swipe."

Paragraph 14 (I think? I've lost track a little):

  • "She did not even pause. Natiselle had pulled her remaining blade and was ducking and weaving around each swipe he tried to land."
    Suggestion: "Natiselle didn't even pause. She had already pulled out her remaining blade and ducked and weaved around each swipe he tried to land."

Paragraph 15:

  • "Suddenly, I could feel a grimy hand at my throat, pulling me to him."
    I don't think she'd know immediately who was pulling her where, so I believe this should be more like "… a grimy hand at my throat, pulling me backwards."
  • "The stocky one that had fallen, I had forgotten about him."
    This might work a tiny bit better if you just arrange the parts. "I had forgotten about the stocky one that had fallen."
  • "I could feel his hot breath on my head, smelling of rot and his last meal. His sweaty shirt clung to my back and I could almost feel it through my bodice."
    You use "I could feel" structures twice. Here's my example to see if it could be avoided: "His hot breath was on my head, smelling of rot, and his sweaty shirt clung to my back. I could almost feel it through my bodice."
  • "Her eyes narrowed as spots danced in my vision and she raised her hand and her dagger flew through the air."
    This is a little bit of a run-on sentence. Try something like "… spots danced in my vision, and she raised her hand. Her dagger flew through the air suddenly."
  • "My knees buckled and only his hand was keeping upright."
    Comma after buckled.

Paragraph (uh… maybe 19? It's in the dialogue portion, so you should recognize it pretty fast):

  • " 'You knew this was going to happen did you not? This is why you brought me here.' Her voice was so quiet and fear shot through me. 'There is no ‘delicious dining hall’ in this region is there?' ”
    It should be more like " '… was going to happen, did you not? This is why you brought me here.' Her voice was so quiet that fear shot through me."

Paragraph (uh…):

  • " 'Why? Are you trying to kill me?' She asked, a singular eyebrow quirking up."

You don't need to capitalize the she.

Paragraph (sorry about this, I really have no way of counting unless I go back through the whole thing- hopefully it's not too hard to find):

  • "…husband.' Finally my voice seemed to find its footing."
    "My voice finally seemed to find its footing." would sound equally as nice.

Paragraph (I mean, this is all in order…):

  • “You owe me now, three times over. You are too useful to dispose of now,” she said, “and I am not an animal. I would never kill an unarmed man or woman. Are you going to stay on the ground in your own filth or not?”
    An alternate phrasing of the first sentence, like "You owe me three times over.", would be fine. I also don't think you need the 'or not' in the last sentence.

Paragraph (sometime after that last one aha):

  • "A puff of air escaped me and I was overcome with relief."
    I'm rather sure there should be a comma after me.
  • " 'Let me see your house gem.' She thrust her hand at me and without a word I pulled the ruby from its place next to my heart. She closed her hand around the golden chain and said, 'Follow my lead.'
    I would do like I suggested earlier and make this into a separate paragraph. Also, as for critiques:
    "… thrust her hand at me, and without a word, I pulled the ruby from its place next to my heart."
  • "She stumbled toward an approaching carriage, her fist outstretched with the ruby swinging and glittering in the lamplight. I did not need to pretend to be tired, my legs felt like lead."
    If you made this a separate, shorter paragraph split from the one I just suggested above, then you could do something like "We stumbled towards an approaching carriage, the ruby swinging and glittering in her outstretched fist…."

Paragraph After That One:

  • " 'Help!' She cried…"
    She doesn't need to be capitalized.

Last Paragraph:

  • "He nodded and the door swung open. I sunk into the cushions gratefully and promptly fainted.
    "
    I would pull these sentences from the paragraph they're currently in to make it sound more dramatic. It'd make these two a little more shocking.

Alright, that's everything. Oh gosh, I nitpicked so hard on you. Please feel free to choose whatever suggestions you like! Not all of them are what I wanted to be, and I know I set them up with explanation paragraphs that were kinda rushed, but I hoped that kinda made some sort of sense :)

Deleted user

@writelikeyourerunningoutoftime
I'll get to yours as soon as I can in the morning! It's almost 1 here! Sorry!!!

@Reblod flag

Oh yeah I get what you mean
The idea was the 'ice rain' represents sleet which is a cover name/handle for one of my characters
The last part heavily focuses on the chaos Sleet/Mara brings due to her madness
Also, it could mean how strange sleet is, ice and rain falling from the sky. Kind of like a two meaning thing

@WriteOutofTime

@writelikeyourerunningoutoftime
I'll get to yours as soon as I can in the morning! It's almost 1 here! Sorry!!!

not to be pushy or anything lol but did u forget me??

Deleted user

@writelikeyourerunningoutoftime
I actually didn't! The problem is that the only computer that works with this program is only accessible once every other day or so. Sometimes I'll get lucky, but most of the time I just have a few hours a day to do what I need to. You're not pushy! I'll get right to it. I thought I'd have time that next morning, but I had lessons that I forgot about. Sorry!

Deleted user

@writelikeyourerunningoutoftime

I'm gonna do something different for this one. Instead of leaving horribly long and slightly messy (sorry!) comments like I did for @LittleBear , I'll just edit the whole thing and leave a note after about what I changed/why I changed it. That way you'll easily see examples of what I thought needed to be mixed up a little without the confusion.

Note: I do like the theme you had going here! It was very descriptive. The sentences that were used for emphasis were done very well. A lot of people skip over those types of sentences in order to make long, elegant, winding ones that often lose the reader's focus. You did a pretty good job of paying attention to both detail and phrasing. The things that I will edit are mostly just sentences in which the message you were going for got a tiny bit lost in the wording.

Let's start, then!

Morning came with pain.

The streetlights outside the window had changed sometime during the night, and now the warmth of artificial UV rays flooded the room with warmth. At that moment there was peace outside Nyir's home, but she could practically sense the riots that would surely be occurring elsewhere.

Nyir felt vaguely disappointed. Sleep hadn't cured her tiredness, nor her soreness. Her eyes felt warm and heavy, like marbles rolling sluggishly through honey. She cursed between breaths.

“Damn it,” she moaned, slowly shoving herself upright. The sheets fell from her bruised body and gathered around her hips. They were tinted red with blood, a sight that made her spit out another curse. Had she torn her stitches?

She ran her fingers down her exposed scalp into her cornrows. The motion was soothing. She repeated it, taking deep breaths, until the rattling in her lungs had quieted to a soft wheeze and the pain was nothing more than a dull ache. Her free hand felt underneath her shirt, tearing off the damp bandages to trace the stitches, which were definitely torn. She’d never been a heavy sleeper. Her restlessness must have ripped them.

“I’m alive,” she breathed. The statement was neutral.

Nyir distanced herself from the wound and thought back over the night before - mostly Evera and everything she had said. She wondered if Evera had arrested the kid anyway, but decided against it. She’d seemed opposed to the idea, and she wasn’t one to change her mind easily. The Northern kid was safe, for now. But would that last?

Her eyes trailed over to the side table. Yuu’mi had been from the North, near the tunnels, and he'd been outspoken about it. Nyir hadn’t cared much about what he’d been saying, but now things were different. If he wasn't speaking up anymore, then who would? Nyir would not let his voice be forgotten; usually, though, his beliefs were just an afterthought. She was too busy to do anything about them.

Shaking those thoughts away impatiently, she forced herself to her feet. Dizziness nearly dragged her back down as the blood rushed from her head. She managed to stay upright as she made her way to the kitchen, keeping a hold to the walls and furniture to support her as she went.

When she got there, Tasper was already sitting at her table with Daso at his side. They were gathered around the radio with mugs of tea, listening to static.

Daso spotted her first and rose to his feet. “Hi, General! Feeling better, darling?”

“Nope,” she replied with a tight smile. “Why’re you in my house?” She sank into the chair across from him. Tasper poured her a cup of tea absently, his eyes still on the radio.

Daso sat back down as well. “Evera sent me. She wanted your permission to employ your regiment to help control the crowd." He gestured quickly to the radio. "She’s about to announce a meeting.”

“Clearance granted,” she responded with a half shrug, lifting her mug to her lips.

Tasper finally glanced away from the transceiver. “Can I tag along, Daso? I’m curious.”

“Sure, kid,” he answered with a smile, “and we’ll swing by to pick up Sacia. No one should travel alone with all this chaos, not even a daring doll like her.”

At that, Tas lowered his head. Nyir could see him thinking. Sometimes, she wished he wasn't so easy to read. "Did you fight with Sacia again?"

“Not really,” he replied, a little too fast, “I just… brought up stuff I shouldn’t’ve. The real problem is the way she treated Mitsig.”

Nyir shrugged. “Sure.” She prepared herself to say more, but the static on the radio changed to a loud voice.

“Attention all Lower World residents: This is Leader Evera. There have been rumors about missing rations, and I must set them straight. Please make your way to the Platform near the stables by 0900 to receive more information. Please trust that you are safe, and the Board is doing everything it can to keep you that way. Again, a meeting at the Platform near the stables at 0900. Thank you.”

The message started over. Nyir shut the radio off and looked at the clock on the wall. The meeting wasn’t for another hour or so. She sighed and shook her head. “You two go on and get there before the crowd. It’ll be hell trying to get there at the same time as everyone.”

“Trying to get rid of us so soon?” Daso shot back with a grin, already standing and pushing the chair back underneath the table.

Tasper finished his tea in one gulp and scrambled to his feet. “Yeah, good idea. I’ll be ready in a moment.” He hurried into the back of the house, disappearing into his room.

“I think Eve’s in over her head,” Daso blurted out the moment Tasper was out of earshot, his smile fading.

Nyir didn’t reply for a long moment, inspecting the shining black liquid in her cup. Finally, she said, “Don’t wait ‘til Tasper’s gone to speak your mind. You’re a kid too.”

Daso’s grin flew back onto his face, but she could see in his eyes that he was hurt. He leaned against the wall, lips puckering. “I’m nearly eighteen, you know!” he joked, standing up on his tiptoes.

“What I meant,” she said, lowering her mug, “was that I won’t hold things back from you, him, or anyone unless I want. It’s never because of your age.”

He nodded. “I know. I know.” A wry smirk appeared on his youthful face. “By the way, Dara got a promotion, thanks to us.”

“How do you mean?”

“The sample we collected.” He smiled, linking his fingers behind his head. “She’s got a theory and she’s going to be running the experiments herself. Leader Simanta herself gave her fifth level clearance.”

She nodded her head, unsurprised. “She was always the better twin out of the two of you.”

“She's the smart one, I'm the pretty one,” he snickered. “Anyway, she feels like she’s close to a breakthrough. She wanted to let you know that.”

Nyir shrugged. "She always says she's close, Daso."

“No, this time’s… different.” A rare serious look spread over his countenance. “She thinks she has a way to really hurt them, maybe even kill them.”

Her hand tightened around her mug, but she purposefully kept her expression calm. Despite herself, her heart rate began to speed up. In a daze, she repeated, “Kill them?”

“Theoretically,” Daso clarified. His face relaxed back into his usual smile, and he laughed, “So, no need to go off on suicide missions anymore, yeah?”

Nyir nodded again, her hand relaxing as well. “Sounds promising. I’ll visit her lab as soon as I’m able.”

They didn’t speak anymore. Tasper returned to the front and he and Daso left, mumbling quick goodbyes. She watched them with a passive eye, her thoughts tumultuous. Her jaw clenched.

A way to kill dragons. She wished she could believe it.

~~~~

There you go! I think that'll make it easier for you to compare this piece and yours. Now, let me summarize some of the things I changed.

Sometimes you had a few sentences that sounded a bit out of place. For example, there was one that said, "Enough about her, she decided." That reminded me a bit of something somebody would say if they were at a polite gathering, not something that a person would consciously decide. In that same vein, there were a few parts that took away from the tension. After one serious bit of dialogue, you added, "She sipped her tea." I thought stuff like that was an unneeded buffer between two quotes.

There were also some situations in which you repeated words in paragraphs that could've been replaced. There was one time in which you used "against it" in two sentences in a row. Another time, you used the word "torn" about three times. Things like that can be fixed pretty easily, but it's still something you might want to watch out for.

Once or twice, you had several streams of dialogue in a row that were interrupted by actions that didn't necessarily have to be there. To make it more readable, I took a few of them out.

Many things I tried not to change at all, and what I did edit I attempted to keep close to the original version.

Deleted user

For some reason it made that whole thing weird, but it should still be there.

@LittleBear group

@ReiniDays, thanks so much for the critique! You caught a whole bunch of little typos that I need to fix so thank you! But my big question was does the fight scene flow? And outside of the grammatical parts, did anything draw you out of the action? Also, @writelikeyourerunningoutoftime your stuff was lovely as always :)

Deleted user

@LittleBear
Thanks! I'm sorry it was so picky, and I hope it made sense!
The fight scene was great! I loved the action and actually felt really invested in the safety of the characters. Those creeps really grossed me out, which is something you want your readers to feel. I don't really know what the Pravaci Court was, but I did enjoy reading about Natiselle's character. She was so cool!
Hey, would it be too much to ask if you could give a quick glance over the thing I sent for @writelikeyourerunningoutoftime ? I don't know why, but it made it that weird font and I just want to make sure you guys can see it/read it well. You don't have to read it in detail or anything.

Deleted user

Oh, and @writelikeyourerunningoutoftime , if that's not readable you can always ask me to send it through email or something. I tried fixing it, but I didn't understand why it wouldn't work. I'm so sorry!

@LittleBear group

@ReiniDays, did you indent anywhere? Sometimes that makes that weird text box. If you click the three dots and click edit, then back space all the indents it should fix it.

Deleted user

@LittleBear
I might tomorrow, if no more critique requests roll in. I'm hoping more people will find this chat soon :)