forum Mary Sue/Gary Stu Challenge!
Started by Deleted user
tune
Edit topic

people_alt 64 followers

@WriteOutofTime

Lol, this reminds me of this one article that said Rey from Star Wars was a Mary Sue and I was like, 'Um, no…. not really.'

Well, mary sues don't have to be as exaggerated as these. They can be more lowkey. Rey isn't 100% a mary sue, but she has some mary sue-esque qualities for sure

@rot-baby-rot!

Percy Jackson Mary Sue:
Name: Sequin Marquette
Godly Parent: lol u thought it wud be Aphrodite, but u r rong! Haha its Artemisand dont tell me she cant hav kidz!! becuz she birthed sequin!!!! If u say utherwize ur a trol, go away!!!1111
Appearance: tall and skinny but she’s also curvy and has hair and eyes that change color constantly (haha u thought only aphrodite kids cud do dat!! uwu)
Personality: she’s sarcastic but nice, smarter than all of Athena cabin put together, everyone luvs her!!!!!! She can build or fix anything, she’s immortal, her dad wuz a king so shes a Princess!!!!! And she’s always happy all the time!!!!
Powers: all of da powers, and she’s dating Nico!!!!

(I apologize in advance for all of the spelling, I was just trying to write like Mary Sue authors often do. They also ship every OC with Nico for some reason? He’s like 14 and he’s gay, so….not a very good choice for your ‘miraculously beautiful’ 19 year old protagonist.)

gods…oh gods…why??? and thank u for the pint about nico…on pinterest i see like hc for thalico,reynico,rachico,etc and im like..NO he is GAY. STOP. WHAT ARE YOU DOING TO MY BABY BROTHER HES FINALLY HAPPY WITH WHO HE IS STOP RUINING THAT. but its a really good mary sue type of charecter

There's also the point that he has a boyfriend?? Like no, he's not dating you random OCs, he's dating Will Solace (it's canon), I seriously don't get the obsession with shipping him with females if it's not platonic
Like, I ship reynico platonicly, because those two could be really good friends

Deleted user

shuriken, "because he's BAT–" I died laughing

Demi, that personality tho

Thanks!

Deleted user

Percy Jackson Mary Sue:
Name: Sequin Marquette
Godly Parent: lol u thought it wud be Aphrodite, but u r rong! Haha its Artemisand dont tell me she cant hav kidz!! becuz she birthed sequin!!!! If u say utherwize ur a trol, go away!!!1111
Appearance: tall and skinny but she’s also curvy and has hair and eyes that change color constantly (haha u thought only aphrodite kids cud do dat!! uwu)
Personality: she’s sarcastic but nice, smarter than all of Athena cabin put together, everyone luvs her!!!!!! She can build or fix anything, she’s immortal, her dad wuz a king so shes a Princess!!!!! And she’s always happy all the time!!!!
Powers: all of da powers, and she’s dating Nico!!!!

(I apologize in advance for all of the spelling, I was just trying to write like Mary Sue authors often do. They also ship every OC with Nico for some reason? He’s like 14 and he’s gay, so….not a very good choice for your ‘miraculously beautiful’ 19 year old protagonist.)

gods…oh gods…why??? and thank u for the pint about nico…on pinterest i see like hc for thalico,reynico,rachico,etc and im like..NO he is GAY. STOP. WHAT ARE YOU DOING TO MY BABY BROTHER HES FINALLY HAPPY WITH WHO HE IS STOP RUINING THAT. but its a really good mary sue type of charecter

I admit that I shipped Reynico before I read Trials of Apollo

@Bianca di Angelo

but at least reynico has some basis in canon though REYNA CANNOT BE WITH A DEMIGOD. but people ship like thalico and im like:
they have interacted like three times
thalia can not be with someone romantically
nico is gay
they dont even like each other????(let me direct you to the chapter where reyna got kidnapped by the hunters and nicos reaction to that)
nico HATES the hunters because of bianca
they show NO romantic interest toward each other
i mean they practically hate each other
LIKE NO PEOPLE. NO
at least reyna and nico actually like each other(not romantically though)
but yh
sorry that was so off topic

@rot-baby-rot!

Have Rachel and Nico ever even interacted? And also, if a person is canonically with another person, I don’t ship them with someone else except in rare circumstances (I.e. AmiLeia and Scarinter)

Yeah, I don't even think they spoke to eachother ONCE in the books. They probably knew of eachother's exsistance, but they were not friends

@NotSoBeautifulDiseaster group

Fandom: Diabolik Lovers Idk why I made an OC for an anime I hate

Name: Amai Ketsueki Komori (Literally Means Sweet Blood Komori)

Age: 18

Looks: Long Wavy Brunette Hair, Sharp Blue eyes, Tall, Curvaceous frame, Big Breast

Nicknames- Doll (Kanato) Melons(Ayato) Neko-sama(Laito) Crazy lady who keeps pretending to be my sister (Yui)

Personality: Sassy, Strong, Smart, Elegant, Sadistic

Powers: All the vampire powers

Backstory: She was the vessel the real but forgetten Demon Lord's daughter, Fritodelia, who had the best blood in the land way better than Cordelia's, Long story Cordelia sniped Fritodelia cuz she was jealous and put her heart into little baby Amai, after that Seiji adopted her and her sister(cousin/doppelganger/daughter/something related) Yui. But he liked Yui more and Yui used to bully her for no reason despite the fact that she killed herself to save her literal abusers, but whatever when she was 12 she ran away and was adopted by super cool vampires and they raised her into the woman she is now

Likes: Beer, Music, Goth stuff, Bats, Horror Movies, Blood
Dislikes: Yui, Seiji, The church, cute things, Yui making mistakes, Yui existing, GOd

Other: All the abusive shits, I mean, guys are nice to her bc she's cool and a badass