Tati
Hey, Atlas, there's a section I wrote that is really long and I feel if probably boring. Can you help me either sum it up or make it more interesting. Here's the section.
In the front of the stage stood my dad. Behind him stood, my mom, Tammi, and Tina. At the back of the room, was a reporter with a camera. No one told me, they intended to film this, but then again it wasn’t my choice to potentially ruin our family’s lives. As we had established, I took my place next to my mom.
Once all the students and teachers arrived, Tammi walked up to the microphone that sat center stage.
“I’m sorry about the interruption, but due to some recent events, we felt as though we had to get this out of the way as soon as possible. Ben, your up,” she said.
As my dad walked up to the microphone, his hands shook. “Hello, for those of you who haven’t met me, my name is Ben Miller. I am twenty-eight years old, and I teach Fairy History here at the Southwater Interspecies Academy. My story is a long and complex one, but I’ll try and sum it up in as short of time as possible. I was born on the last day of what is known to - to my kind as the Destruction.” He paused as a number of presumably fairies gasped.
“When I was born there were only three other fairies left in the Old World; my birth mother, and my adoptive parents. My parents adopted me and left the old world in what they thought was the last ship left. From there we traveled six months before we got trapped for nearly five years in a star system named Salut. It means timeless in the Old Language. When I was five years old, my eyes were opened to the harsh reality of living on a planet and among a people that felt that you didn’t belong. Six months later, I begged my mother to make me human and she did and for twenty-three years the process transformation that usually occurs in fairies passed me by. But I shortly realized that even though I didn’t look like a fairy or have magic, the human kids at my school still saw me as a fairy. One day, when I was thirteen, someone broke into my house. She looked me dead in the eyes and drained the life out of my parents.”
My dad glanced back towards my mom, gulped, and looked right at the camera as he said, “After she was done, she walked up to me and said, ‘Hello, Ben, my name is Alex and I’m your mother.’” There was a collective gasp in the audience.
“I just looked at her, shellshocked and said, ‘You're not my mother, you're the woman who murdered my parents.’ and ran off. Over the next several months, I would learn of the atrocities that Alex had committed, and of her agenda to murder the girl that I loved. It was then that I decided that as long as I shall live, I would never allow Alex Howler to hurt anyone I love ever again. Thank you.”Alright, before I get into what I'm going to say, I would like to address this sentence: " It means timeless in the Old Language."
So while I read, the story flowed nicely, until I got to this. Instead of feeling like this was part of Ben's speech, it felt like you, the writer, tried to cram information in. Which, hey, I've done that a lot, in hopes of getting everything in, but when you try to put extra information in like this, even if it's a small piece, it throws the reader off.
It's not something we need to know- and if I had never known what the word meant, it wouldn't have changed anything. You could keep it like that if you'd like, it's not that big of a deal, but I feel like if you wanted to incorporate this small piece in, there are cleverer ways of doing so. Again, not a big deal, but I thought I'd point it out.Now for the rest of the writing. Yes, you're right in the fact that it's a little "boring", but when one of your characters is talking about their past in efforts to change the perspective of others, it's going to be a little boring, it's an informative piece and necessary, so not everything you write is going to be engaging enough as say a fighting scene.
When I read this, I felt as if though this was something that needed more build-up. This is a big moment for Ben to come out and talk about something like this when he knows that this is a potentially dangerous subject. He risks putting everyone he loves in danger because of the stigma that a certain species are dangerous, people might want him or his family dead to eliminate the threat.For a second I'm going to step away from criticism and give you my opinion on the matter. You can take this with a grain of salt if you like.
Personally, if Ben was my character I would like to see him at his limit. Have him give this speech when he's come close to losing his daughter, his wife. Maybe someone died because they thought Ben and the people he associated with were these horrible people that weren't in actuality. Maybe after this has happened, he beats himself up for it and wishes he would have said something sooner to give his perspective, so that they would have known that he wasn't like his mother.
I think it would make for an emotional scene and give just a little more meaning to his speech. I feel like it's too soon for Ben to start talking about his past, it's something that should unfold through the story- but then again, this is just my opinion. If you have a reason for having Ben do his backstory so early in the book, then that's definitely okay! As long as you structure everything nicely, then there are no problems.
Thanks! The plan was that after this scene, the council (fairy government) orders a trial for him on suspicion of treason. They only come to the assumption because his mother is murdering psychotic and wants the Queen dead. Also, later I was going to have it that Amelia has trouble in her new classes, so, Ben feels guilty. He thinks it's his fault because he left Amelia and her mom when she was two and so he never prepared her for the possibility of this now being her life. Also, at one point Alex ends up killing Tina and they all carry a certain amount of responsibility for her death.
What do you think?