forum Scene Critiques
Started by Blue Duck
tune

people_alt 7 followers

Blue Duck

Hello everybody!

We are a group of English students looking forward to sharing our experience, mistakes, and advice to you guys.
This is something our team is not used to doing but is excited to try out. We will critique your scenes. Unlike the characters, you will only get one (really thorough) opinion that looks at both the physical things (spelling, punctuation, etc.) and the techniques used (literary devices, character development, etc.). We offer no time frame, as we like to analyze things way too much, but will try to get back to you as soon as possible.

Happy writing!

-Blue Duck Team

@Paperok

Thursday, August 18, 2016

11:28 AM.

"Just about everything in this class is physical," Mrs. Indram snapped at Paul. He shook off wherever his mind was wandering to and shifted uncomfortably in the chair as she continued to berate him.

"I don't own any gym shorts," he said again. He had come to her office during lunch to see if she had any gym shorts he could borrow. Apparently, all she intended to do was growl and lecture.

"Buy some," She took a glance at her watch and stood up, she was a small old woman but in top shape. She donned a tank top and red shorts. "Youll have to sit to the side until you have a pair, and some better shoes," she threw a disgusted look at his flip-flops and socks. "Anything would be better than that," Paul considered hissing at her. the bell rung, he jumped a bit, unadjusted to this school's loud bell. "Get out to the gym." He left her office following the hallway into the gym while enjoying the defiant slap of his flip-flops on the floor. There were already students coming in the doors on the other side of the gym and going into their respective locker rooms, taking their bags in there and changing into gym clothes. Paul had already put his bag in the locker room.

"I like my flip-flops," Paul muttered. The gym wasn't anything fancy, a basketball court some bleachers on two sides and a high ceiling. The rest of his gym class was gathering on the bleachers sitting in a line on the bottom level. There is another class too, a weight training class. They've stayed in the lockers and in the weight room for the last few days. Paul sat on the bleachers in between some guy named Tony and a girl named Kihara. Mrs. Indram paced in front of them, calling out names over the general chatter of the other students, he plucked awkwardly at his jeans as she went down the list. The wait for his name to be called always makes him tense. "Paul Fenn."

"Here!" He watched her continue listing names while regretting wasting the last ten minutes of his lunch coming here. His friend, Logan, was absent. He didn't have anything else to do. The thought of making a new friend crossed his mind. One of the doors on the other side of the gym opened. It wasn't the opening of the door that shocked Paul. It was the loud slam that followed behind it. A girl stood in front of the doors, he recognized her, short shoulder length brown hair, a backpack hanging off her left shoulder, she wore a button-up shirt and black jeans. She stood in front of the door, eyes wide as if the the loud slam had given her a heart attack. Paul watched for a moment as the girl strolled across the basketball court; then her bag slipped off. Paul stared, expecting the class to explode with laughter as she knelt down picking up some scattered items. A quick look to his left and right revealed that no one seemed to care. he was the only one paying attention, she locked eyes with him. He looked away. She picked up her bag and gave Mrs. Indram a tardy slip. They spoke for a minute, Mrs. Indram seemed to be angry about something, the girl went into the girl's locker room. Mrs. Indram came over to the students "We're going to the track, let's go" There are two things beyond the parking lot in the back of the school, the football stadium and the soccer field beside it. Paul thought back to the clumsy girl, was she going to catch up?

"You don't have any gym shorts?" A rather tall boy spoke to him, he shrugged a bit, unsure of what the boy was saying. The boy held his gaze,

"No," Paul said "I only do jeans," he chuckled and Paul relaxed some. What a weird conversation. Maybe he could be Paul's new friend, he recalled seeing him in another class. That's at least two classes together! They got to the Football stadium, inside, around the field was the track, six lanes. Mrs. Indram led them onto the track.

"Paul, Jessica, c'mere" Mrs. Indram nearly shouts. Paul made my way toward her and noticed the girl from earlier walking beside him, when did she catch? She is still wearing her black jeans. Mrs. Indram directed them to a tree "sit, don't talk." Paul sat against the tree and watched her line the class up. It took him a moment to notice the girl named 'Jessica' sitting next to him. He glanced awkwardly at her, what did she want? He caught her eye and they stared at each other for a moment

"Do you have any gum?" she asked in a monotone voice. Paul continued staring blankly,

"No."

"Do you have any snacks?"

"No," her face sunk and she scooted away some. Paul watched her for a moment and turned back to the class, they were running around the track.

"Its the mile run," Jessica was staring at him again, he avoided her eyes. "It's like four laps around the track or something" he nodded, looking up at the almost perfectly blue sky. He preferred cloudier days, not as bright.

"That sounds fun," he said giving her a smile, she wasn't amused.

"How is that fun?" She leaned close, furrowing her brow.

"I was being sarcastic." Paul looks down, eyes hurting from staring at the sun.

"Sarcasm will get you nowhere in life." She scooted back over to him,

"Neither will trying to take other people's snacks"

"I didn't try to take your snacks. Wait, you have snacks?"

"I said don't talk!" Mrs. Indram yelled at them from the apparent starting line.

"What does she want us to do?" Jessica groaned.

"Wallow in regret" Paul suggested with a shrug, there is a bit of silence.

"Let's face away from her so she can't tell were talking," Jessica said.

"Why?" Paul said,

"So we can talk," they both shifted a bit so they were facing the school grounds. Despite what she said, Jessica didn't seem interested in talking, she simply watched her shoes. Paul took this moment to stare at her. she was a conventionally pretty girl: full lips, high forehead, broad face, small chin, and nose, short and narrow jaw, she wasn't skinny or exactly large. Paul felt as if he was supposed to be attracted to her, he wasn't. Perhaps he didn't like her personality, Paul shifted slightly to face her.

"This class is unnecessary," he said

"It's pretty important," she said "can't have the next generation being out of shape." unable to think of a good response he goes silent again. A few minutes passed. "What is your favorite color?" Jessica asked,

"I don't know, blue or something," Jessica responded strangely to this, Paul noticed her staring at him again. In response, he stared back. "What about you,"

"Red," she said, scooting an inch or so closer to Paul. Was she trying to make a move on him? Paul internally cringed at the thought. His mind was doing backward cartwheels while wondering what exactly a backward cartwheel was. This could simply be the way she is, she could simply prefer to be up close while she's invested in a conversation. Another possibility would be she wanted to kiss him. Was Paul flustered? "Are you alright?"

"Yes, I"

"Quiet over there!" Mrs. Indram yelled again "Keep talking and I will send both of you to the office!" Jessica humphed at him and smiled, Paul didn't notice himself smiling back. It wasn't like they were friends, it was simply a passing interaction between strangers.

Friday, August 19, 2016

1:15 PM.

Paul's last hour class was in the furthest west building, Building 7. He had to make his way there on the covered walkways. The walkways were a system that reached every major location in Raulerson High. Brushing some sweat off his forehead, Paul cursed the size of the school.

"Paul, wait up!" Jessica came up behind Paul, "you left so fast." She said breathlessly. He met her the day before, but they had been spending an immense amount of time together since. It came to his attention that they had every single class together.

"I didn't have anything to do but to get my backpack," Paul said, "if you want me to wait, all you have to do is ask." Jessica humphed at him and the two continued walking. Paul wasn't sure what was happening with Jessica. she acted as if they had been friends for years. He didn't dislike her.

"You should buy some shorts," Jessica said,

"I will," Paul said.

"We're starting partner activities next week, I want to be partners with you."

"That's why I should get shorts?" Paul laughed softly,

"You don't want to be partners?"

"I doubt I would be able to keep up with you," Paul teased, recalling how nimble she was while Mrs. Indram had the class running suicides. "You are surprisingly athletic."

"Surprisingly?" Jessica crossed her arms and lowered her head slightly, "I used to play soccer," Paul looked her up and down only half surprised. "I was a forward."

"A forward?"

"That's right." The pair reached the entrance to Building 7,

"What's a forward?" Jessica explained to him what a forward was as they entered Building 7, inside was a hallway and a stairwell. They started up the stairwell as Paul came to the conclusion that a forward was essentially a running back.

"You'll be my partner?" Jessica asked, Paul shrugged,

"If I get shorts then yeah," he said, Jessica nodded flashing a toothy smile. They reached the second floor, Paul held the door open for Jessica but regretted it when six other people passed through after her. He cursed his act of kindness before stepping into the hallway. Mr. King, their last hour teacher's classroom was right beside the entrance. Jessica had already walked inside. Some students had gathered around the entrance and were talking. Paul's twin sister, Crystal, was talking to her boyfriend by the door. Wearing a striped t-shirt and skinny jeans, Her neon purple hair was laid flat on her shoulders. Crystal was Paul's twin sister. Naturally, his absolute opposite. Where he was lacking in intelligence and physical activities she had advanced classes and was more fit than some of the boys in their grade. But that didn't matter to Paul. She'd protected him from bullies and such all their lives, it was good to have her around. She was upset about something, Paul noticed her balled fists at her sides as he approached.

"What are we doing?" she asked. Her boyfriend, Paul gave up on trying to remember his name the moment he'd met the guy, looked down. "What. Are. We. Doing?" She demanded again. Paul snuck past them as she continued. Crystal could be defined as a grown woman stuck in the body of a teenager. Especially when it came to her "romantic endeavors," she acted as if they were already married. Paul entered the classroom and saw that the seats were arranged into groups of four. Jessica was in the group closest to the door, the only person there. She happily waved Paul over. He sat down in the seat next to hers.

"What happened to you?" Jessica asked flipping through her notebook for no apparent reason.

"Got held up being a gentleman," Paul said. He dug his notebook out from his backpack and placed it on the desk before checking the time on his phone. 1:19 PM. The class was about to start. Jessica was leaning over searching through her bag, Paul watched for a moment as some of the students who were standing outside of the class came inside. She straightened up and turned towards Paul. "Why even bother looking," he said. "You already know you don't have a pencil." She played with her notebook paper for a moment before speaking

"Can I borrow your pencil?"

"Yes." Paul opened his backpack, got his pencil pouch and gave her a sharpened pencil. "I should charge you a dollar,"

"I have a dollar," she said as a girl sat down across from me.

"Keep it," Paul said.

@LittleBear group

Let me know what y'all think!

Erion -

“The subject is Halis Onrin,” Maious said. “He will be in his residence in the Selian district.” He handed me a slip of parchment.

If my memory of Canise served correct, the Selian district was the richest, other than the Palace.

“What has he done?” I asked.

“Not a concern of yours,” he said, dismissing me.

Knowing better than to protest, I left the room. But I stayed close to the door, straining to hear as best I could.

“Keep your eye on that one, Anions. We never should have taken an Uradavi in,” Maious said to my handler. “His conscious will be the end of us. If he has anything of his mother, then his will is unbreakable.”

“The boy asks a good question. I myself am curious,” Anions said.

“Smuggler. The King wants his wares, a poison of some kind, off the streets,” Maious answered. “The assignment should be easy enough. He will be alone.”

Satisfied, I put space between myself and the door. The risk of a beating was not worth the extra gossip.

He is a drug lord, a thief, a liar; the King has ordered his death. This is no different from a soldier obeying orders, I told myself. This was not murder.

((I’ll write them riding through the city later, too lazy to do it now))

We tied up our mounts a little ways away and Anions turned to me. “Quickly, quietly, and the house burns after us. No traces. Understand?”

I nodded.

The only sound was the whisper of wind though the date palms. Nothing was awake apart from Anions and me, even the crickets were no longer playing their song. The grand house was one of many, all stark and beautiful against the vast desert sky. And most importantly, a second story window was open.

He glanced around and nodded to me. Quickly, we made our way to the wall, I gave him a boost, and he disappeared into the house. A moment later the end of his whip fell down the wall. Just as we had practiced so many times before, I wrapped my hand around the whip and walked up the wall.

“Do not touch anything,” he breathed as I clambered into the room. An office, by how it was furnished.

“I am not an imbecile,” I muttered to myself as he made his way deeper into the house, his footfalls barely a whisper.

I slipped after him.

We made our way through the house. At every turn I could not help but wonder at the splendors that were here and how they differed from the opulence of home. There were lush rugs inlaid with golden scenes instead of tapestries and painted porcelain instead of crystal vases. The home smelled faintly of incense, snuffed out hours ago.

We finally came to a set of double doors, and, as was the usual for Lianian architecture, they led to the bedroom. Anions motioned me forward with one hand and slowly opened the door with the other.

I drew my dagger, took a deep breath, and slipped through. A large bed took up most of the room, just as expensively decorated as the rest of the house. It was occupied by huge Lianian man who was snoring soundly, his barrel of a chest rising and falling. I crept up next to him and looked down at his face, obscured by a well-groomed black beard.

“I am sorry,” I breathed. He is a drug lord, a thief, a liar; the King has ordered his death. This is no different from a soldier obeying orders, I told myself again. This had become my mantra.

I dragged my knife across his throat – quickly, cleanly, and through both arteries, just as I had practiced on the pigs. His eyes flew open and his snores were replaced with the gurgle of blood in his newly-ruined throat.

I stumbled away from him and scrambled back through the door.

The moment I came through the door, Anions grabbed my collar and forced me to look at him. “Breathe boy. You have done well, but the job is not over.”

I nodded and we each went to a lamp and poured the oil out onto the floor, darkening the beautiful carpets. Simultaneously we lit our matches and let them fall. The light that followed blinded me for a moment and all I could see was the dark liquid flowing from his neck.

The way it shined in the moonlight was seared into my memory.

“Come,” Anions said. He pulled me back the way we had come, out the office window and towards our mounts. When we finally turned to look at the house, it was engulfed in flames.

“You did well. But it is time to return,” Anions said and for a moment I felt a spark of pride. A spark that I immediately squashed down, for it was pride that threatened to rot my insides.

I was about to reply when I heard a scream and then a crying babe shortly after.

No.

Before I could process what was going on, I was running back to the house. I did not get far.

“There is nothing you can do now. What is done is done!” Anions had my forearm in a vise.

“There is a babe in there! You said he would be alone!” I roared.

“Sometimes the intelligence is wrong. You did not verify,” he said matter-of-factly, as if we had not just condemned the life of an innocent.

“May Rionel have at you,” I cursed as I drew my sword and smashed the pommel into his face. It was if Lehion himself was guiding my hand, for Anions crumpled immediately.

I did not bother with the window again; instead, I went for the entrance. I tore off my headscarf and held it to my mouth before I put my boot through the grand window. The smoke that billowed out stung my eyes and burned my throat. With a last prayer to Lehion, I stepped into the inferno.

“Where are you?” I yelled over the roar of the flames and the groaning of the house. What had seemed grand only minutes ago had transformed into a hellscape. “Where -” I was racked with a coughing fit.

“Help!” the voice called, clearly feminine, just loud enough to be heard over the cacophony.

“Keep yelling!” I shouted and followed the voice through the house.

Suddenly, an almighty groan rose above the rest. I looked up and saw a beam bow and then break. Luckily, I leapt forward just in time to escape its crushing blow. Plaster rained down around me and added to my urgency. After what seemed like an eternity, I came to the woman’s door. A burning armoire had fallen in front of the door

“I am here. Hold on!” I yelled. “Move away from the door!” I bit into my headscarf and used both hands to lift my sword high over my head. I do not know if the fire had just weakened the wood or if it was the adrenaline coursing through my veins, but I made short work of the armoire. I shoved the pieces and the blankets that it held aside and grabbed the door handle. White-hot pain screamed up my hand before I could realize my mistake.

Cursing, I grabbed my headscarf again then grabbed the handle and pulled.

The woman was crouched in the farthest corner of the room, a nursery. She curled around her child, trying to keep him from the smoke that swirled all around her. When she saw me, she leapt to her feet and rushed forward. She was barefoot.

I sheathed my sword and grabbed her.

“No!” She screamed, terrified. It was then that I realized that she was only in a thin shift.

“You are barefoot – I will have to carry you,” I croaked. “Here, take this.” I handed her my headscarf.

She nodded slowly. I swept her and the baby into my arms, and I stumbled back through the house.

“Go through the back,” she shouted, straining to be heard over the blaze, “It is much closer.” She became my eyes as I stumbled through the deadly maze, shouting a new direction every few moments.

When we finally came to the back door, the world was beginning to spin and my entire body was shaking. “Hold on,” I wheezed and I kicked the door open.

We spilled into backyard and clean air flooded my lungs. The woman and her child tumbled out of my arms just before my stomach heaved. I narrowly missed them when I vomited black sludge into the grass. We laid there for a moment, with the sound of the dying house taking over the night.

“Thank you,” she whispered. “I do not even know you and you saved us. How can I ever repay you?” Her words were worse than the raging fire.

“Forget that I was here,” I said as I picked up my headscarf and rewrapped my head. “Tell everyone that you got out yourself.”

“But -” she objected.

I was already walking away from her, towards the back gate. I had to face the Anions’ wrath. I skirted the edge of the property and slowly made my way back to where I had left him. But he was not there. Cursing, I started towards the horses.

I had not made it five paces before someone appeared behind me and wrapped his arm around my throat. Instantly spots danced in my vision. I slammed my fists at his arm, but the effort was feeble. My strength was gone.


Hot.

That was the first thing I noticed. The heat was oppressive. I could not tell if the wetness on my face was sweat or tears. The salt burned my eyes and my parched throat screamed at me for water. But when I tried to wipe my face, I realized how truly, deeply wrong things were. I was in stocks and there was a roaring fire in a hearth not ten feet away. “Let me out!” I tried to scream, but my throat was too dry, producing only a harsh and guttural sound.

There was a gust of cool air as the door opened and the Spy Master strode in, a bucket in one hand, cane in the other. “Ah, the princeling awakes,” he purred as he rapped my chin with his cane.

Without thinking, I lunged forward, causing the stocks to jerk.

“And yet still so hostile,” he tutted. He crouched so that he was level with me. “You do not understand. Your dear mother has given me all the license in the world. We will break you, Uradavi; keep you dancing between life and death until you learn.” Then he threw the bucket’s contents at me. Cool and beautiful water.

“Three hours more. Then I want him in the throne room,” he said as he left. “Call all the apprentices in. I want the consorts too. Bring –” and the door closed, locking out all the cool air.

I think I made it another thirty minutes before passing out again.


This time, the air was mercifully cool. But, I could tell that I was not alone. There was the gentle hum of a confused crowd. I took full stock of my position before I opened my eyes. I was not wearing a shirt, I was bent over on something curved and soft, and my feet were solidly on the ground. Most importantly, my wrists were tied down.

I opened my eyes and immediately wished I had not. I was indeed surrounded by a crowd. Everyone was in the throne room. All the other apprentices, instructors, and guards were watching me. Even the courtesans were here. Instantly I knew what was coming.

“There he is! Let us begin then!” He said, his voice like a like velvet. Gods, he was going to paint it as entertainment. “Thank you so much for joining us today for the trial of Janon Hane.”

“His crimes include questioning orders, disobeying orders, reckless endangerment of mission, reckless endangerment of self, attacking a handler, and endangerment of identity. Thus – ”

“The babe would have burned to death!” I squawked. My throat burned in protest.

“Oh, let us add interrupting me to the list! I will be merciful – five lashes for each infraction. That brings us to,” purred as he mimed counting on his fingers, “thirty-five. Anions, you do the honors.”

The crowd fell completely silent and I knew that all my gods had left me. There was no getting out of this.

It felt as if the air had turned to molasses. Each of Anions’ footfalls took an eternity and the pounding of my heart drowned out everything else. He came and tightened my bonds, his face drawn and almost remorseful. “Forgive me.”

I focused on the Spy Master, lounging in his throne, grit my teeth, and gripped the bonds. There was a crack and instantly I felt a blinding pain across my shoulders. I jerked but did not make a sound. I wound not give him the satisfaction.

My mind goes to another place. A place where I cannot feel the skin curling off my back or the blood dribbling onto the floor. A place where I can repeatedly punch the Spy Master in his teeth. I did not take my eyes from him. I pulled all my strength from my hatred of him and drew joy when he straightened in his throne. I realized he wanted to hear me call out. He wanted to hear me break.

I would rather die before breaking.

“Stop!” he barks after the tenth lash. The tension leaves my body. “Bring his partner.”

My heart drops.

“Unhand me!” her pretty voice shouts. “I have done nothing wrong.”

Two guards come through the crowd, a blonde twisting and thrashing in their grip. Her hair is disheveled, she is still in her dressing gown, and it looks like there is a hand print blooming across her face. They brought her directly in front of me and I could see that it is unmistakably Sela.

“Janon, my God,” she cried, “What have they done to you? What is going on? I am so scared.”

“If you will not cry out for me, perhaps you will do so for her,” the Spy Master growled.

He would not dare. To mar a courtesan would be the same as condemning her to death. No man, no matter how pretty the face, would deign to let an imperfect courtesan warm his bed. He would lose all that he had paid for her and she would have to take to the streets.

“So be it. She will take your remaining twenty-five.” His grin brought bile to my throat.

“What? No! Please, master! Please!” Sela screamed, dropping to her knees.

He was bluffing.

I made no move. No sound.

“Oh, you do not believe me!” His smile turned predatory.

He stormed down from his throne and grabbed one of the guard’s whips. He was bluffing.

I watched in horror as he drew it back and it snapped across her back. The sound seems to reverberate across the room, louder than the others were. With a cry, she fell forward. Her gown was torn and blood was already flowing from her flesh.

What had I done?

The Spy Master raised his hand again and he has won.

“No!” I roared.

There is no pride left to fight for.

“Stop. Please,” I said. “Have mercy.”

Triumphantly, he lowered his hand and called out, “Proceed, Anions.”

Again, the whip whistled through the air and it cracked across my back. And I screamed. I screamed like an animal in the throes of death.

My poor, parched throat cracked again and again from the force. The pain came in waves. It was relentless.

My vision swam and Sela blurred away.

Soon, it was too much to exclaim. All that escaped were pitiful whimpers. Then the cool fingers of darkness dragged me under and I felt nothing at all.


An unholy moaning filled the room and crashed in my ears, like a tempest’s waves on the shore. Put the poor man out of his misery, I want to say, but then it dawns on me. I am the man. I am the moaning. My mind was heavy, stuffed with cotton. But I felt nothing.

She appeared like an angel and put a cool hand on my forehead. “Shh,” she soothed. “I am so sorry, Erion. I am so sorry.”

Why? Why is she sorry? “No…” The words are hard to form. “I have killed you.”

She sobbed and covered her mouth.

“No, no,” she choked. “I am so sorry, Erion. It was all fake. Every moment of it. They found me beforehand and threatened – they said they were going to kill you if I did not act out the scene.”

I did not understand. There was blood. Her gown ripped. “They ruined you.”

She shook her head. “It was paint. It was pageantry. The dress was already torn when they brought me to you. When I heard the sound, I was supposed to fall forward and pretend.”

Her words were confusing and it grew harder to muddle through them. She faded away just as she appeared. Maybe she was a dream.


The first thing I saw was my bandaged hand. It smelled strongly of something sharp that irritated my nose. With my good hand, I tried to push myself up and suddenly I was on fire. There was nothing but pain. My world was pain and the air filled with cries.

“No! Do not move!” Suddenly Anions was there. He guided me back down and forced something into my mouth. “Swallow, boy.”

Hopefully, he has come to finish me off.

Darkness comes again and I greet it happily.


I could feel his eyes on me. He was sitting on the floor, leaning against the far wall.

“I had no idea what they would do to you,” he murmured. “I am sorry Erion. What you did, I respect you for it. None of us here would have done that.”

As I fell asleep again, I could not help but think that that was the first time he had used my true name.


((Back in Estonie, much later on in the book))

Finally, there was a knock at the door. If it was not so worrying that Delpe was so late, I would be cross.

“Enter,” I called as I selected a shirt from my office bureau. “Where have you been, I expected your…”

I turned and froze. The person at the door was not Delpe. It was Eline.

Cursing, I yanked the shirt on.

“Erion, your back…” She was as white as a sheet and her hand was at her throat. “What happened to your back?” she asked as she stepped forward.

“Nothing.” My mind was racing.

“Those are not from sparring or battle. These are whipping scars. What happened over there?” She reached out to me.

“I said –”

“Do not lie to me. I know what I am seeing,” she whispered.

I could not do this. No one could know. “No,” I said. And pushed past her. I could not be here.


Someone knocked furiously at my door and within seconds, I had my dagger in hand.

I wrenched it open and found Eline standing there. With a heavy sigh, I tucked my dagger into my trousers. “Eline, what are you doing here? If someone sees you here, the scandal –”

“Fie on scandal!” she spat. “I care about you more than the prattle of gossipmongers. What happened? I will stand here all through the night if I have to.”

“Do not do this to Solin. You cannot be here,” I begged, willing Tian to give me patience.

“If he knew, he would be here as well. Let me in. You have nothing to bargain with.” She crossed her arms and glared at me.

I let her in. It was no use.

Blue Duck

@Paperok

Hey!
My name is Brooklynn, and I was the one critiquing your scene. Some general notes that I have are are try not to switch time periods, and to de-word your sentences. I know that last point is kinda strange, but a ton of your sentences had unnecessary words that made it clunky. I would also like to see some description of Paul. What does he look like. Not going to lie, but your characters seem super flat. By flat I mean boring. I was finding it hard to relate to them. You have amazing ideas, but try to add some human characteristics when they speak. Add in details like how they are feeling. Don't be afraid to use sentence fragments when writing dialogue. I really enjoyed the general high school tone of the scene. One last point is to expand the words you use. Instead of saying "said" all the time, switch it up with "replied", or "asked".
Great work though! Here is a link to the google doc that I edited your scene on. I encourage you read through the edits I made, and then decide which ones you want to keep. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1R2HPXOLDnIqMf6Gh-Twga7JX6J4r8QVrySoXfkWs2Qs/edit?usp=sharing

If you have any questions, feel free to email me at [email protected]

Happy writing!

-Brooklynn

@Riorlyne pets

(@Blue Duck - just something I have had issues with in the past and figured out the hard way: when sharing a Google doc that has comments, the privacy settings need to be set so that everyone with the link can comment, otherwise your original comments can't be viewed. :)

Blue Duck

@LittleBear
Hi!
My name is Delta (but i go by D)
I'm the one in charge of your scene, and I'm currently transitioning my comments onto the google doc! Sorry for taking so long but school piled up really quickly…
The critique should hopefully be published within the next few days!

-D

@SupernaturalSyGuyIsTIred group

A woman with butt length blonde hair laid on the hospital bed with her legs in stirrups; she was getting ready to give birth. Her hospital gown was light pink, and her hair clung to her forehead. She had light blue eyes. She’s a woman of a slender build, and stands at the height of 5’5”. Her face is slightly rounded and her cheekbones are somewhat high. A man with dark blonde hair stood to her right, holding her hand. He has a light brown goatee, brown eyes, and a light brown mustache. He is very handsome, with a medium sized nose, and somewhat high cheekbones. He’s wearing a light blue smock over a white t-shirt and jeans. He is wearing light brown work boots. A nurse with long, dark brown hair and a slender face stood beside the bed, and the doctor stood at the foot of the bed. The room that they are in has tiled ceramic flooring, and two large windows that open up into a beautiful flower garden that rests next to a lake. The brick walls were painted light green.
“Alright, Morgan. Just one more push!” Said the doctor.
“Come on Morgan, push!” Her husband urged. Morgan had been in labor for 17 hours. She had gone through immense amounts of pain, and now screamed out at the top of her lungs. Her husband, Griffin, winced as Morgan tightened her grip on his hand. Finally their baby was out in the world. The nurse handed Griffin a pair of scissors.
“Congratulations, it’s a boy!” Said the doctor. He handed the baby boy to the nurse, who carried him off to take his vitals and clean him. She came back with Morgan and Griffin’s son swaddled in a light blue blanket. A little light blue hat was placed upon his head. Morgan took her son in her arms, and felt love for him. She smiled with pure, unadulterated joy. She looked up at Griffin.
“Do you want to choose his first name?” She asked him. Griffin smiled down at her and their son.
“Jason,” Griffin responded. “After your great grandfather. What about his middle name?” Morgan looked up at him, smiling as a tear slipped out of her eye.
“Oliver, after your great grandfather.” Morgan said. The nurse came up with a clipboard, and a birth certificate. Griffin took it from her, and wrote ‘JASON OLIVER FLAYME’ down. Jason weighed ten pounds and six ounces. He had very light blonde hair, and light blue eyes.________________
Griffin, Morgan and Jason walked through the red door of the gray house. Their entryway consisted of light red ceramic tiling, a gray area rug sat in the hall. The walls were an earthy-red, and pictures of family members hung from them. A little boy wearing blue overalls that had a little bear on the front and a red shirt underneath came running up with his arms spread. His brown eyes shined with joy, and he was yelling for his mommy and daddy. He was barefooted, and had blonde hair. Griffin scooped him up in his arms, and held him tight.
“Were you good for your Aunt Sarah, Connor?” Griffin asked. A woman with light brown hair walked around the corner. She was wearing jeans, and a white floral blouse. A pair of slim glasses rested on her face. She beamed out a smile, ran to Morgan, and wrapped her arms around her.
“Connor was wonderful Grif.” Sarah said before holding out her arms to hold Jason, and Morgan handed him to her. They moved into the living room. The living room had toys strewn about the light brown ultra plush carpeting. The walls were light green, and had some family pictures hanging on them. An oak coffee table sat between the light tan sectional leather couch and the twentysix inch flat screen TV. Sarah stayed for a little bit, eat dinner, and had small talk with her family. Connor was fed, bathed, changed, and put to bed.
Morgan and Griffin sat on their memory foam bed which sat on an ornate metal frame. A red cedar crib sat near the foot of their bed, and held Jason, who was fast asleep. The blanket on Griffin’s and Morgan’s bed was an ultra plush, king sized maroon comforter. A large walk-in closet was to the right. The carpeting was white in color and heated. Pictures of Morgan’s and Griffin’s family were on the wall, and there were mahogany nightstands. A twentyfour inch TV sat in the wall. Morgan let out a sigh, and Griffin turned to face her. He noticed that Morgan had a strange look on her face.
“Are you alright babe? Do you want me to grab the trash can?” Griffin asked her. Morgan shook her head.
“Griffin. I have to tell you something, but you have to promise me that you won’t get upset.” Morgan told him.
“Of course.” Griffin said after several minutes of silent worry. Morgan took his hand, and looked him directly in the eyes. She had a very serious expression on her face.
“I-I was,” Mogan paused, and let out a sigh. “Raped.” She started to cry. Griffin looked at her with a confused look on his face.
“What do you mean?” Griffin asked.
“I mean that Jason isn’t your son!” Morgan started to cry even harder, and Griffin pulled her in for a warm, sheltering embrace. He tried to hide the anger that was boiling up inside of him for the monster that had raped his wife, but it showed in his eyes and face.
________________
A six year old Jason Flayme was lying in his bed; a thermometer hung out of his mouth, and a wet washcloth rested on his forehead. His blonde hair laid on his Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles pillow case, and a matching blanket loosely clung to his body. His face was square and slightly rounded. His room had a single window in it that looked over the yard. An oak toy box sat at the foot of his bed, and the flooring was a green carpet. The walls and ceiling were painted to make it seem like the room’s furnishings were outside. Two pine dressers were against a wall, a eighteen inch TV sat on top of a small square table between them, and a hamper sat at the other side of the dressers. The bed that Jason was on was a red, gold, and blue bunk bed. Jason shares the room with his elder brother, Connor.
Morgan sat next to Jason on a blue chair. She was wearing a light blue dress and nothing on her feet, her hair was pulled back into a ponytail. She pulled the blue and white thermometer out of his mouth when it started to beep. She looked down at it.
“Your temps one hundred two sweetie, so you won’t be going to school today.” She reached out, put the back of her hand on Jason’s forehead, and quickly pulled it away. Jason’s skin was hot to the touch. At the age of nine, scorch marks would be found around Jason.
________________
Jason is now ten years old. His blond hair frames his young, slender face. He sits in Miss Parker’s class reading a Goosebumps book, and gets excited by the part that he’s reading. The book starts to become dark in the center, and then spontaneously catches fire. Jason drops the book, and screams. Miss Parker, a short, yet stocky looking woman with red hair and green eyes, immediately looks over, grabs the fire extinguisher, and puts the flames out. She gets down to Jason’s level, and gently chastises him before calling his parents.
“Hello, this is Samantha Parker at East Midtown Elementary. May I speak to Griffin Flayme?” She holds onto the phone as she’s put on hold and transferred.
“Hello?” Griffin says.
“Hi Mister Flayme; this is Samantha Parker at East Midtown Elementary. I’m calling about Jason.” She says.
“Jason? Is he alright?” He asks her.
“Jason seems alright. I just had to put the book that he lit on fire out.” She tells him, and after calming him down she explains to him what happened. Griffin is relieved that Jason and all of the kids are alright. Later on that day when Jason gets home he’s grounded for starting a fire. Strangely, nobody wonders how Jason started a fire in the first place. He was placed in his room, alone, and the TV, toys, and books were removed. He was left with only a paper, and a pencil to write why what he had done was wrong. As Jason started to write, he became angry that no one had asked him what really happened, and the paper ignited. He quickly put the fire out, and wondered what was going on. He got up, and put the burnt paper in the trash. As he turned around, he noticed that the pencil was burned where he held it.
The next day at school, Jason was talking to a group of his friends.
“I can light things on fire, and leave burn marks on things.” He says. One of his friends, Jack, looks at him and guffaws. Jack is wearing a green long sleeved shirt, jean shorts, and Spider-man shoes. He has medium length black hair, a cream-like skin tone, and blue eyes.
“We know that Jason.” Jack says.
“No, you don’t understand. I can burn things with my mind!”Jason exclaims. People look over at him, and laugh at him. Jack rolls his eyes.
“Sure, and I can use my mind to kill people.” Jack says sarcastically.
“Here, let me prove it. Just hand me a piece of paper.” Jason pleads. Jack’s twin sister, Jane, hands him some paper. Jason takes it from her, and tries to light it on fire without success. Jack lets out a sigh of aggravation before turning around, and walking away with the group. He turns around.
“Stay away from us you freak. We can’t be seen with a weirdo like you, you freak!” Jason balls the paper up in his hand, and heads to lunch. While in lunch Jason is called ‘freak’ and ‘fire starter’ by several people. His anger flares up, and the decorative poster next to him catches fire. A paraprofessional sees the poster go up in flames, and sees Jason in front, facing it. She pulls the fire alarm, and activates the sprinklers. After the fire department leaves Jason is called into the principal’s office.
The principal is a woman of a tall stature. She stands at 5’9”, has long brown hair, and wears a long black pant suit. She has a pair of slim black glasses over her normally sparkling blue eyes. She sits on one side of her mahogany desk facing Jason. A bronze name plate reading ANNA B. CAMPBELL rests on the desk along with a stack of papers, and a computer. Motivational posters hang from the light gray walls. A sliding window rests in one wall.
“Now Jason, why did you light the poster in the cafeteria on fire?” Anna asks him. Jason just sits there in his chair, looks at her, and doesn’t answer. Anna reaches over and pulls out a file. She asks Jason if he knows what it is, and he shakes his head no in response.
“It’s your permanent record Jason. Do you know what that is?” She asks.
“No.” Jason responds honestly.
“It keeps track of your grades, and your behavior. This will go to any school that you go to, and will even be there for when you get a job. You’ve always been such a good little boy, but sadly I must write in that you like to start fires.” She opens the file, grabs a pen, and writes that down as Jason sits there. Anna picks up the phone, and calls his parents. Several moments later they arrive, and talk to the principal alone while Jason goes to his class. They come out of the office angry that Jason was suspended for the rest of the year, but was allowed to have his homework brought home to him by Connor.
At home Jason is reprimanded for his behavior, and becomes angry. Morgan and Griffin ground him for a month, and Jason tries to explain to them what happened. Morgan adds another half month to Jason’s home confinement. She and Griffin are so angry that they can’t even speak. Morgan finds that her pet fish, Goldie and Alex, are dead. Upon further examination she discovers that the water in their tank is warm. She has Griffin dispose of them, and Griffin finds out that they were boiled alive. Later that day, Jason is petting their pet Calico, Snickers, in the yard when Snickers scratches him. Jason yelps in pain, and Morgan and Griffin come running. Snickers scurries off, and curls up in a sunny spot in the grass. Jason glares at Snickers, and Snickers catches on fire. Morgan and Griffin witnessed this happen, and were now somewhat frightened with Jason’s ability. Jason’s hair has gone from blonde to a dark blonde, and his eyes become a mixture of blue and brown.
Jason is playing a fighting video game with Connor. Connor has been cheating, and has also beaten Jason multiple times. Connor is now fourteen years old, had naturally dark blonde hair, and was wearing light blue shorts, white ankle socks, and a white t-shirt. Jason was wearing light green sweatpants, and a green t-shirt.
“No fair; you're cheating!” Jason says.
“No I’m not. You just suck.” Connor responds as he activates a cheat code to make it so that he can take three more percent away from Jason’s character’s health away. Jason gets upset when he loses for the fifth time in a row.
“Please let me win the next round.” He pleads to Connor.
“Alright, you can win the next round.” Connor says, and then starts the next round. He lets Jason take most of the health from his character away before laying down a beat down on Jason’s and winning the match.
“WHAT THE HECK WAS THAT?” Jason screams. Connor just laughs at him, and then starts to get an expression of pain on his face. Smoke rises up from his clothes, and they catch fire. Connor runs outside and desperately rolls around on the ground before making a mad attempt to rend his clothes from his body. The smell of burnt flesh starts to flood the air, and the only sound heard is Connor’s screams. Griffin and Morgan run outside, and watch in horror as their eldest child is burned alive. Griffin makes an attempt to put the flames out to no avail. Jason just stands there watching with his mouth wide open as he watches Connor writhe about in pain before succumbing to the hungry flames. Morgan and Griffin weep for their son as the paramedics and the fire department, which were called by a neighbor, arrive. A week later a closed casket showing of Connor was held, followed by his funeral. From that day on, Jason starts wearing dark clothing.
________________
A twelve year old Jason wanders the streets. His teachers have become afraid of him, and so have his parents. As a result of their fear, Morgan and Griffin kicked Jason out, and told him to never return. He was wearing a faded blue sweatshirt over a blue t-shirt, and faded blue jeans. He was wearing a pair of old red, white, and black New Balance tennis shoes, and wore a black and orange backpack. His face was losing the baby fat that clung to him, making his face even more pleasing to look at. He walked into a McDonald’s and just stood staring at the menu. One of the cashiers asked him what he wanted, and he just frowned at her. She wore a red t-shirt, a little name tag, and black hat with the McDonald’s logo on it. Her flowing brown hair was done up into a ponytail, and had a streak of light blonde coming down from the left of her head.
“What’s the matter bud?” She asked. Jason looked up at her.
“I don’t have any money.” He says. Just then a kind older man steps up behind Jason, and lays a hand on him. He’s wearing a tan suit, a white tie, and lightly scuffed tan dress shoes. His graying brown hair is gelled and combed back. He has a kind looking face, and brown stubble where he would have a beard and mustache if he didn’t shave.
“I’ll pay for whatever the lad wants, lass.” He says. Jason orders two double cheeseburgers with ketchup only, french-fries, chicken nuggets with barbecue sauce, and a large chocolate shake. The kind man invites Jason to sit and eat with him, and Jason accepts the offer. How could he not after what the man just did. They get their food, and go sit down at a table.
“Thanks for paying for me.” Jason says to the man. The man stops Jason before he can start eating.
“T’was my pleasure lad, but before you start eating we must pray for our food.” The man said. Jason was confused.
“Why?” Jason asked.
“My good lad, I’m a priest at East Midtown Baptist. My name is Father Thomas McCreedy. Everything that is given to us, be it life, or food, is a gift from God.” He said.
“Oh…. I’m Jason.” He says before taking Father Thomas’s hand to shake it. He follows Father Thomas’ actions, puts his hands together, closes his eyes, and bows his head. Father Thomas starts the prayer.
“Dear Heavenly Father, thank you for the wonderful bounty that young Jason and I are about to consume. Please bless it in your name, and thank you for bringing me here to help Jason. Amen.” Jason says amen after Father Thomas does, and looks up to see people glaring at them.
“Why are they staring at us like that?” Jason asks before picking up some fries. Father Thomas smiles at Jason’s question.
“Despite America being a country where its citizens have religious freedoms, it is not acceptable in society to pray in public.” Father Thomas responds. They talk about where Jason would go after he leaves McDonald’s, and Father Thomas offers to take Jason under his wing. Jason gladly accepts the offer, and follows Father Thomas to East Midtown Baptist Church. Jason stays at the church and learns about the KJV Holy Bible for two long years. He was kicked out when Father Thomas had caught Jason accidentally using his powers. He had accidentally melted a giant metal crucifix.
“Jason, what have you done?” Father Thomas asks.
“N-nothing.” Jason says.
“You have just melted a crucifix with fire that you can control. Pack your things, leave from this church, and never return again. You are devil’s spawn, and no spawn of Satan shall live under the roof of God, now away with you!” Father Thomas said in anger. Jason went to his room, packed his clothes, his bible, and some food. One of the other priests knocked on the door frame, and caused Jason to jump and turn around. The priest that had knocked was Father James Simpson. He had buzz cut brown hair, and a clean shaven face. His green eyes shined as he looked at Jason.
“Fear not my son. I come not to chastise you, but to offer a helping hand. I can’t do much for you, for I would be excommunicated if I were caught helping you with a lot of things. The best that I can do is pay for your food, clothing, and schooling. I have talked to Father Thomas, and he agrees that even ‘hellish devil’s spawn’ should have clean clothing that fits, food to eat, and a good education. He had only agreed that I be the one to pay for these things. When you are in need of money for food or clothing you are to simply knock thrice upon the door, and I will come with money for what you need.” Jason thanked Father James, grabbed what he needed, took some money and a wallet from Father James, and walked out of the church for the final time.
Whilst living on the streets again, Jason had accidentally burned down several houses of families while the families were gone. Luckily nobody was hurt or killed in the fires, and the families were all families that had dogs that went on trips with their owners. The neighbors, however, had seen Jason and called the police. Jason was arrested more than once for arson, and was held at the Central Midtown Juvenile Detention Center. He has been in and out of the juvenile center several times.
________________
Officer Johnny Shark walked up to Jason. He wore a light blue uniform, and a bronze badge. A taser hung from his hip, and a police cap slept on his head. He has brown eyes, brown hair, and is of a muscular build.
“Flayme, you’ve got a visitor.” Johnny said. Jason stood up, and went with him after his cell was unlocked. Jason’s hair and eyes are now naturally brown in color. Officer Shark is careful not to touch Jason’s skin, for it is naturally hot to the touch. The walls, ceiling, and floor of the cell were bare. The only thing that was in the cell was a chest for Jason’s clothing, bedding, a sink, a toilet, and a bed. Jason was wearing a light green striped t-shirt, green sweat pants, and green shoes. All he could think about was who in their right mind would actually want to visit him. He walked into a large, circular room that had two levels of cells. The walls were white, and the floor and ceiling were gray. Ten square tables were on the bottom floor. The tables are made of steel, and have chairs attached to them. Officer Shark walks Jason, now handcuffed, to a table that has a woman with long, blonde hair at it. She’s wearing a leather riding jacket, jeans, and boots. She has blue eyes, tan skin, and large breasts. Her face is square in shape, but rounded at her chin. A black helmet sits on the table. She immediately smiles at Jason. Jason sits down across from her, and Officer Shark stands near them.
“Who are you?” Jason asks the woman. She continues to smile at him.
“Who am I? I, young man, am your Aunt Loraine, and wife to your Uncle Dan Heilig. I’m your adoptive father’s sister, and a psychic.” She said. Jason looked her up and down, leaning his head from side to side.
“I’ve never heard of you, and what do you mean by ‘adoptive’?” Jason said after being silent for a while. Loraine laughs.
“I’m not surprised. Your adoptive father and I had a falling out before you were born, but not before your brother was. I told him that some horrible thing was lurking, waiting in your house, and that something horrible was going to happen. Needless to say, he didn’t believe me. We fought about it until he told me to go, and never come back. Griffin can hold grudges for a very long time.” She told Jason.
“So I’ve seen.” Jason said in reply. Griffin and Morgan wanted nothing to do with him, and left him to rot in the Central Midtown Juvenile Center. This was actually more so on Griffin’s part. Morgan, despite being afraid of her son, still loved him. She wanted to take care of him, but Griffin had wanted nothing to do with ‘the boy’. Loraine frowned for the first time since she arrived, and nodded.
“What I mean by ‘adoptive’, is that Griffin isn’t your biological father, but your adoptive father!” Loraine tells Jason.
“How would you know that?” Jason asks.
“I had a vision of whatever lurked in your house molesting your mother. Sadly this particular vision hit me a year after you turned six years old, when your powers started to emerge, so I couldn’t warn your mother and Griffin.” She said.
“Oh really?” Jason said with a raised right eyebrow. Loraine nodded in response, squinted her eyes, stuck a small portion of her tongue out of the side of her mouth, and nodded yet again.
“You have a gift of your own Jason. I can sense that you don’t believe me about being a psychic, so I’ll give you proof.” Loraine said. Jason wasn’t shocked that she knew that he didn’t believe that she was a psychic.
Psychic my ass. Jason thought. “Anyone that tells someone that their psychic will always say that.” He crosses his arms. He’s able to do this, for there is a chain between each cuff for low risk inmates. The low risk inmates wore green, the medium risk inmates wore yellow, and the high risk inmates wore red. The medium risk inmates had to wear cuffs that had an adjustable chain between them. The high risk inmates were required to wear cuffs that were hooked to a chain that wrapped around their waists. They were the only inmates that had to wear cuffs around their ankles. Loraine leaned forward to whisper into Jason’s ear.
“I know that your brother, Connor, died whilst on fire; a fire that you created with your mind.” She whispers. Jason stares in shock, and Loraine reiterates everything that had happened to Jason before leaning away from him. She wore a knowing smile on her face.
“How do you know all of that?” Jason asks. Loraine continues to smile.
“The power of the psychic shows up sporadically on your adoptive father’s side of the family. You, Jason, are the first one in the family with your particular… abilities.” She stands up, and walks over to Officer Shark. She tells him something, and then walks back to Jason.
“I’ve paid your bail Jason. Learn to control your abilities; you’re going to be using them again. Good luck Jason.” She grabs her helmet, starts to walk away, but turns around.
“Oh, I forgot! Jason, all of the events that have transpired up until this point didn’t happen by accident. Remember this; at this time in your life your powers are in their developmental stages, and tied to your emotions. You have a purpose; a mission if you will. These past events are just your origins!”

Blue Duck

@LittleBear
Ah! I finally got a break in my time to do this!
Ok, so some things to work on, you tend to switch between present and past tense a lot. So I don't quite know which one you would like to stick with, but just pick one and keep with it the whole time (I do the same thing and Brook yells at me for it all the time so don't worry)
Also, I didn't know the main character's name because he had so many…
I really like the plot you have! The world seems really cool, maybe just explain it more because it was kind of confusing sometimes.

Here's the link to the google doc: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1fm9-f6O9utw4J1qLmto8XCe6V_PLSPIyLAP82YlIkKs/edit

If you have questions, email me at [email protected] and address it to D

Happy Writing!

-Delta

@painters_tape

Hello! A few notes about my scene before I put it out here, this is the opening scene of what might be a short story but also might end up a novel, so the characters are quite complex in my mind and are still being fleshed out. Feel free to review their character descriptions on my page if anything about them or the nature of the world itself is confusing. Thanks for doing this!!

The dry heat had turned to humidity inside the shabby black cab of the carriage. Sweat dripped down the brow of William Todd, one of the three occupants of the cab, and ran into his eyes. He swiped at it and glanced out the dull window next to him, hoping to be reassured they would arrive soon; but the only consolation he received was that the sweat on his face would turn to mud as soon as he exited the transport. A cloud of reddish dust had engulfed them as they drove, the dry and choking sister of fog.

There were two things Will was sure of as he sat staring out at the dust. The first was that he didn’t much enjoy the London countryside, at least from what he’d seen. The second was that they wouldn’t need to stay very long at the Belleview manor. He’d read of their impossible claims ― certainly he had, as everyone had ― and he knew that it wouldn’t take long to prove them frauds. Stories like this always led to dead ends.

One of the horses whinnied, snapping Will’s attention back to the cab. The carriage jolted under them, throwing the two men in the seat opposite Will into each other. An unintelligible shout from the driver rang out as he attempted to calm the horses. All three men looked at each other, none quite sure what the problem was, and none quite brave enough to ask; a strange feeling had settled over Will, a hot-cold dread in the pit of his stomach that crawled up through his rib cage into his heart, trapping his breath for a moment. Then the feeling passed, and a clearing opened up before them. A large, dark and weary looking manor jutted up from the ground like a gravestone, sudden and a little wrong. Despite the sweltering heat of the cab, a chill ran down Will’s spine. Immediately, he chastised himself for being so easily spooked.

“Remind me again why we’re bothering to investigate this?” John growled, exasperated. His head smacked against the wall behind him as the carriage slid to a sudden halt, knocking his hat onto the floor. He rubbed the back of his skull and grumbled under his breath.

Harry picked up his friend’s hat and set it back on his head, rapping the top with his knuckles. “Because head of house sent us, that’s why.”

Will put his hand on the door. “Let’s get on with it, shall we?”

As the three men stepped out of the transport, the dust clung to their skin just as Will thought it would, mixing with their sweat to create a grimy, gritty sheen. The June sun was high in the sky, burning bright spots into their vision. They had just begun to unload their luggage from atop the cab when the door to the manor creaked open. A man dressed in a dark suit stepped out, smiling at them. It was a smile that looked genuine, felt genuine, but never quite reached his eyes. For a moment, the man stood there in the shade of the porch, observing his guests as they finished unloading their things. Only once the carriage had set off again, empty this time, did he speak.

“Gentlemen,” he said with the same odd smile. “Welcome.”

Nobody moved for a beat. The three men covered in sweat and dust looked up at the man of the house, and Will felt like an ache in his bones that something more than just his smile was odd. Something intangible, perhaps even sinister. Then Harry bounded forward to shake his outstretched hand, and the moment evaporated.

“Pleased to finally meet you, Mr. Belleview,” Harry said brightly. “My name is Harry Brighton. These are my colleagues, Mr. John Kingsley and Mr. William Todd.”

Will and John stepped up to shake his hand as well. Mr. Belleview surveyed them once more with a sharp eye. “The pleasure is mine. Now, before you come in, there are a few things I should make you aware of.” His smile didn’t drop as he spoke, but seemed to contrast the bright spark in his eyes in a rather alarming way. “I know you came here with the intentions of proving us to be frauds. You aren’t the first, and you won’t be the last, but I must warn you that you will see impossible things here. With regards to your well-being, I advise you all to leave your skepticism at the door and proceed with open minds. Doubt is not a welcomed guest in this house.”

He let the silence sit and stared down at them. Will discovered that he couldn’t quite meet Mr. Belleview’s gaze. Finally, Harry found his voice. “Yes, sir. We’re all fairly open-minded people.” Which was a lie. But Mr. Belleview seemed satisfied and opened the door, ushering them inside.

Inside the manor, a heavy atmosphere seemed to hover above them all, pressing down on Will’s chest. The decor was just as dark as he has expected, but something about the interior seemed infinitely more alive ― something beating and brooding ― than the deadness of the exterior. Everything in sight was polished mahogany, garnished with brass electrical lighting and crystal vases. A staircase with an emerald green runner swept down the right side of the foyer, and on one of the lower stairs sat a girl dressed in a high-collared black dress, with brown hair shorn close to her scalp.

“This is my daughter, Selene,” Mr. Belleview said, gesturing at her. She allowed them a cool, minute nod that did nothing to diffuse her intense gaze. “Selene, where are your sisters?”

Selene didn’t acknowledge her father’s question, or even his presence, but two other girls emerged from a door behind the staircase before he could ask again. One was tall and full-bodied with chestnut hair and was dressed in an emerald green dress. The other was shorter with sharp features, snowy blonde hair, and wore a dress the color of fawn; her arm was looped through her sister’s, whose eyes were unfocused and unseeing.

“Ah, here they are. These are my other daughters, Lorelei and Calista,” he said, first motioning to the taller one, then to the shorter. “Girls, these are misters Brighton, Kingsley, and Todd.”

Each of the girls nodded at Will and his companion as they were introduced. Will noticed the same odd smile Mr. Belleview wore played on Calista’s lips as she surveyed them with a certain curiosity and intensity. Her gaze fell on each of them for a moment, one after the other. “An investigator,” she said softly, first pinning Harry under her stare. Next was Will, who felt as if her eyes might bore a hole into his head. “An artist.” Finally she looked at John, who was already scowling at her. “And a journalist.”

“Calista,” Lorelei murmured, staring into the air next to her.

Calista ignored her, continuing to look at John. Turning his hat in his hands and matching her fiery stare, he said steadily, “It’ll take more than that to convince us, miss.”

“How quaint,” she remarked, a dimple appearing in her cheek as her smile deeped. She let go of Lorelei’s arm and took a step toward John. “You think you’re scary. But, Mr. Kingsley, I’ve seen scary ―” she took another step towards him and almost sneered “― and you haven’t got his smile.”

“That’s quite enough, Calista,” Mr. Belleview interrupted. Calista’s sneer melted into her odd smile again as she stepped back and took Lorelei’s arm once more. Mr. Belleview turned to his guests, who were bewildered by her strange outburst. “This way, gentlemen. I’ll show you your rooms.”

As Mr. Belleview turned towards the staircase, Selene stood up from her spot on the stair to move out of the way. Without warning, the whole house seemed to shudder under Will’s feet. Selene’s gaze snapped to his, pinning him in place with her eyes, as the world seemed to close in and grow dark around him. The air was being drawn out of his lungs. Time seemed to freeze, an eternity passing in only seconds, in which Selene’s strange yellow eyes burned into his.

“Will!” Harry was shaking his arm, quite forcefully, for Will had fallen to his knees. “Can you hear me? Are you alright?”

Selene wasn’t looking at him anymore. His head was spinning, making the room sway around him. Stinging pain traveled in waves up from his kneecaps into the rest of his body. Every hair on his body stood on end as Harry helped him to his feet, steadying him as he swayed. Will gulped down breath after breath, worried the room would start to jolt again.

“Yes,” he said, mouth dry as sand. “Yes, I’m alright. Just got dizzy. I’m fine, thank you.”

Harry stared at him. “Are you sure?”

“I’m sure.”

Mr. Belleview turned and proceeded up the stairs as if nothing had happened, like men randomly fell to their knees in his foyer all the time. Perhaps they did. Following behind Harry as they ascended the staircase, Will wondered if it was wise for them to be there at all. He wasn’t superstitious, but he didn’t make a habit of collapsing, either. And yet, maybe he had just gotten dizzy. Maybe he had imagined Selene looking at him, imagined the shaking house. Maybe he was just being paranoid. Yes, that was it. Simple paranoia.

They reached a landing that split off into a hallway in both directions. Mr. Belleview turned to the left. Without looking back at them, he said, “The right wing is off limits unless accompanied by myself or one of my staff. Please don’t think I mean to hide anything ― the right wing is simply where my daughters sleep.”

“Of course,” Harry replied.

Continuing down the left, Mr. Belleview pointed to three consecutive rooms. “These three are yours. Divide them among yourselves as you like.” He turned suddenly to look at them, no longer smiling. A suspicion, a wariness, seemed to be his resting expression, dark eyes resting on each of them like lead weights.

Harry broke the growing silence. “Thank you very much, Mr. Belleview. You’ve been very accommodating.”

Mr. Belleview waited a beat. “I hope you’ll all be comfortable. I’ll leave you time to get settled in.”

No sooner was he out of earshot than John turned to Will and Harry, eyes wide, and muttered, “This place is even stranger than I’d expected.”

“Well.” Will looked at John, who was hardly ever surprised at anything, and had to laugh. “At least you’ll have lots to write about.”

@amber_is_in_a_loop

It was a gaze that spoke of loss, of love, of memories shared and retrieved. Of life. The trace of her touch, the ghost of her smile, the black and white tracks of her long-forgotten voice. The colours she had brought with her into my life, from the start, until the finish.

Time had stolen my vision of her. The soft auburn curls gathered on the top of her head, the curve of her cheek bone, her fragile, pale figure, the slight shadows cast across her jaw when she closed her eyes, the crooked smile, the shine of her blue eyes, the faint yet permanent mark on the bridge of her nose, put there by the ridiculous glasses she had once sported. All these details I had once cherished, slipping away from me a little bit more each day I had tried so desperately to hold onto them.

Now I had her back, and all the stories told, the laughs shared, the fears admitted were closing in, forming a barrier separating us from the world. She stood here in front of me, the pitcher slipping from her hand, shattering on the cobblestone path. My Lili. My love.

She took a tentative step forward. I followed. She was close enough to touch.

“Nathan.” It was one word, barely a whisper, quickly swept away with the wind and accumulated years of missing the girl who was now in front of me, repeating the one word I had, for so long, hated above all else.

I reached forward, my hand grazing her cheek. She carefully cupped my hand to her face, laughing gently. She wiped away the droplets of rain crawling down my cheek, mingling with my tears, and I tucked behind her ear the strand of hair fluttering in the breeze. The sun had dipped below the mountains, and the surrounding world of shadows framing her face and invading the sky washed away, leaving nothing but us, Lili and Nathan, desperately clutching at a long-lost love, feeling, for the first time in four years, nothing but joy.