@Vitae_
Theodore visibly faltered, mind going blank as the violence he expected was replaced by a tiny girl about his age shushing him. Should he be offended he'd just been shamefully quieted by a potential enemy or remorseful because she had a point? He settled on confused, with a healthy dose of wariness mixed in.
"And why would I go with you?" he demanded, mindful of matching her volume. He pushed himself back onto his feet, quickly putting some more distance between them until his back was a mere few inches from the wall. His earlier plan to give himself an advantage in fighting off attackers had just ended up leaving him cornered. Again, he cursed his impulsivity.
Just to the right of his right boot was his knife, but Theo made no move to dive for it just yet. He didn't want to give this girl any reason to attack him since, strangely, she hadn't already. 'A trap?' he wondered, a shiver traveling down his spine at the notion. The albino girl didn't look like much, but if he'd learned one thing after the end of the world, it was to not trust anyone.
His fingers inched towards the small, metallic cylinder in his pocket, and with a flash—literally—he flicked the flashlight on and directed it right at the girl's eyes. His heart pounded, blood rushing in his ears, but—
No, she definitely wasn't from the Far Side.
He lowered his flashlight, an apology at the tip of his tongue for the unprompted sensory assault, but a sudden movement in the corner of his eye caught his attention. Someone shuffling quickly past a space in the shelves, headed towards the exit. 'There's more, they're trying to close me in', was one of his last coherent thoughts before the adrenaline of the situation forced him to act.
His eyes darted toward the albino girl again, wincing at her reaction to the light and wondering if her senses were augmented in any way, before sending up a quick prayer to whatever god might be listening. Theo slung his backpack off his shoulder, catching it in the crease of his elbow and promptly throwing it right past the albino girl. He ducked and closed long fingers around the hilt of the kitchen knife and leaped the counter again, this time landing with a solid thump right next to his backpack, which he snagged with his free hand as he pointed the knife threateningly towards Misty.
Taking slow steps back, facing the inside of the store, he raised his voice just loud enough to be heard by both girls—because, now that he was closer to the exit, he could see the other one in perfect clarity.
"What is this, a trap?" he called distrustfully, eyes darting between the girls. "Working together to close me in and steal my supplies? Well, you can't have them. I don't have enough," he added firmly, glaring this time at the blonde girl as if daring her to attack. That was before his whirling thoughts registered the scent of blood, heavy in the air, and the wounded way the blonde was holding her side.
For the second time in several minutes, his brain stuttered to a stop. The tip of his knife lowered just slightly, and he swallowed nervously. "This is a trap, right?" he said, sounding far less certain this time around. "You guys are friends?"
Even as he said it again, he knew he was wrong. Unless the blonde girl was really good at acting and had access to a large amount of fresh blood… 'She needs help,' his brain informed him, and this time, Theo shushed himself.