forum I wouldn't call it constructive criticism...
Started by Deleted user
tune

people_alt 2 followers

Deleted user

I'm just looking for someone who can critique/edit/revise/do some constructive criticism on my story. I'll go section by section, and you can go over the thing and make any little comments.
-It's a mystery. I'm trying to add the element of suspense.
-I'm not gonna tell you everything beforehand, I want you to tell me if you can figure everything out nicely with what I've written.
-I can handle some mean stuff, but don't yell at me, please. It's called constructive criticism for a reason.
Kay, first section!
“Phillis City Police Department, how can I help you?” Private Wanda Retendo answered the phone lazily, leaning back in her chair and ripping apart - quite savagely - a jelly-filled donut.
“I locked my keys in my car.” The caller answered.
“Call your car insurance manager.” Wanda hung up and looked over to Jeremy Z. Goose, who was brushing powdered sugar off of his beak. The bird would need a bath today, she decided.
Jeremy looked up at Wanda and honked. She honked back. “You need to wipe your mouth,” She mumbled to the goose. He honked again.
She got up, pushing out of her office chair and striding to the bathroom across the hall. She took a wet paper towel back to the room, throwing it at Jeremy. “Do some work with it, Jeremy Z. Goose,” She ordered.
Jeremy messily wiped away the jelly, kicking the towel Jordan style into the trash bin. Wanda applauded dimly.
The phone rang again.
“Phillis City Police Department, how can I help you?” Wanda answered, bored.
“My cat’s stuck in a tree, officer.” Explained the caller, in a very fake southern accent that might have belonged to a high schooler.
“We don’t do that kind of work, sorry.” Wanda sighed. Prank caller, of course.
“But officer-”
“I’m sorry, but no.” She replied in as sweet of a voice as she could muster at the moment, and hung up. Jeremy honked loudly. “That’s right, Jeremy Z. You tell ‘em.”
Jeremy bordered on an ear splitting airhorn noise, and Wanda spun her wheely chair a few feet away. “Wait until we get another prank caller, Jeremy Z. Then you can unleash your cuddly Canadian wrath.” She grinned. Jeremy grinned back.
The phone rang a third time. Jeremy got to it before Wanda, however,
And time went by this way at the Phillis City Police Department in Phillis City, Canada. Wanda and Jeremy ate donuts, answered calls, wiped their mouths, played trash basketball, and were overall lazy.
That is, until Wanda was called in to stand guard for a crime scene downtown.
“Private Retendo.”
“It’s Private Wanda.” Private Wanda looked up to see Commanding Officer Taylor looming above her.
“Private Retendo, do you enjoy sitting at that desk every single day you work at this police department?”
“Well, I-”
“Good, because you’re going to get up.” Taylor handed her a duty belt and walked away briskly. “Outside in three, Retendo.”
Wanda turned to blink at Jeremy. Jeremy blinked back, expressionless.
“You heard her, Jeremy. Outside in three.” She strapped on the duty belt and got up from her chair, devouring the last bit of her donut. Jeremy grunted and beat his wings, leaping out the door into the parking lot where three police cars lay in wait.
Wanda ran out behind him, boots stomping on the tile floor. The heat of southern Canada in the summer hit her like a wall, and she squinted, skidding to a stop in front of the cars.
“Get in,” Taylor commanded, opening the door of the first and sliding in.
Wanda gunned her engine and Jeremy grunted, barely closing his door before the car sped off after Taylor’s.
“Taylor, can you explain?” Wanda spoke into her walkie talkie.
“Sorry, no can do now, Retendo. You’ll have to wait until we get there.”
“Get where?”
“Just follow my car, Retendo!” Wanda sensed that Taylor was getting rather annoyed with her. Jeremy grunted and opened the glovebox. Out tumbled out lots of gum and mints. He tore open a mint with his beak and ate it. He holds out an stick of gum for Wanda, who pops it in her mouth.
It’s not a very long drive to the crime scene, although neither of the pair know it yet. To them, it strikes them as strange when they pull up at a roped off little wooden house. It would have been quite a pretty place if it hadn’t been half-obliterated. Taylor jumps out of her car and pulls the door open for Wanda.
“Taylor, what is this and why are we here?” She asks, keeping far away from the ropes.
“One of the guards we had set for guard duty on this scene are not available, so you have been called in his place. You will patrol around the wreckage - do not enter the building - until your patrol is up. At that time, a squadron will come to receive you.” She explains, pushing a tranquilizer gun into her hand and walking off.
“Wait!” Wanda calls. “What about Jeremy?”
She can almost hear Taylor rolling her eyes. “The goose can stay right next to you. Do not let him more than two feet away from you at any time.” She turned the corner and went into the building, disappearing from sight.
Wanda turned to Jeremy. As usual, he stared back.
The two cautiously step under the rope. Walking slowly around the dilapidated building, taking into note every little thing. A rocking horse lies, dirty and cracked, on top of chunks of brick and ashes. A scrap of paper - a picture, once that used to lie in a frame.
“This is terrible. What even is this?” Wanda mused, stepping over bits of asphalt scattered by the blast. Jeremy grunted, slouching.
“Who did it - and why?” Wanda continued, shuffling through the ashes. Nothing like this ever happened in Phillis City. Something was amiss. Something was suspicious.
Of course, this was just Wanda’s detective mind starting to whirr. There was, of course, a reasonable explanation behind all this - something innocent and dull, like a bursted pipe, or a drunkard crashing his car into the gas tanks.
But why did a team of quarantines dressed in all white dash into the building just as she turned the corner? Wanda turned to Jeremy.
“Something’s fishy, Jeremy.” She lowered her voice. “Something very fishy.” Jeremy nodded and grunted.
“Should we investigate?”
Jeremy, being the always-loyal physical conscience, shook his head madly. Wanda sighed.
“I know we were supposed to just keep patrolling…but something’s up. I need to investigate.”
Jeremy poked her pant leg. Wanda sighed and kept walking around the building, stopping occasionally to observe a scarred trinket or a rather large piece of stone that needed to be moved.
“Oh - I’m so sorry.” Wanda bumped into another patrol as she rounded a sharp corner. “I didn’t see you there.”
“Don’t worry, I didn’t see you either.” The man smiled at her, and was about to keep walking, but Wanda called out.
“Hey! Um - you’re one of the normal patrol, so, do you know anything about what’s happening?”
The man turned to Wanda. “I only know some things - a disease broke out a couple weeks ago, and finally the city’s medical board decided to evacuate the building. But somebody bombed the place before they could get to it.” He shrugs. “That’s all I know. Have a good patrol!” He said, then walked off again. Wanda exhaled slowly.
“Somebody bombed the place…” She turned to Jeremy. “This is a lead, Jeremy.” She grit her teeth. “We can’t investigate now - the medical team is inside the building. But we’ll have to come back.” Jeremy made an excellent facepalm for a goose.
That evening, the police squadron came back to pick up the two. As the pair drove back to the station, Wanda sat deep in thought. Someone had bombed the building - something that would never happen in Phillis City. Why had someone done this, and how? And most importantly, who?

A Name With No Girl

DISCLAIMER: I usually don't write/read in english, and I am nitpicky. Some of those comments are more subjective.

  1. Answered "lazily"? Maybe it works in english and I'm just not aware of that, but in my mind it sounds a little… weird. I don't know how someone answering "lazily" sounds.
  2. (not a must, but a suggestion) From the opening we're supposed to understand that the PCPD has no real emergensys to adress. So maybe the first caller could be in a bit more panic, and Wanda be less patient.
  3. Wasn't Jordan a basketball player? In my opinion, when you describe kicking you should use football/soccer players rather than bsketball players (however it's a goose which has no hands so idk. Never had to write gooses before ><")…
  4. UNNECESSARY. The scene makes the boring routine in the station very clear, and so does the sentence which comes before that segment below.

    And time went by this way at the Phillis City Police Department in Phillis City, Canada. Wanda and Jeremy ate donuts, answered calls, wiped their mouths, played trash basketball, and were overall lazy.
    That is, until Wanda was called in to stand guard for a crime scene downtown.

  5. I thought that Jeremy was an actual cop until he beat his wings. Maybe that is what you have intended, but if not - make it more clear.
  6. It feels like Wanda and Jeremy are the only people/gooses in the station, which doesn't make a lot of sense to take them out and leave no one to answer calls.
  7. Hmm… Should'nt it be "IS not avaliable"?

    “One of the guards we had set for guard duty on this scene are not available"

  8. Kinda UNNECESARRY

    Something was amiss. Something was suspicious.

  9. There is no reason to not tell wanda about what she is needed for before she gets there. Also, the vibe is a bit too calm for an explosion (No screaming, panicing people, no blood or something more disturbing than a picture, burnt smell and a dead hourse? What about reporters, since it is so unusual? Why the other guard is so cool about it?). Furthermore, in such a small place, unless it has been like only an hour or two after it (although even so, I think that everyone would hear, talk and freak about it within less than one hour) everybody would probably know about what happened.
  10. Did Wanda and Jeremy drive by themselves to the crime scene or took a ride with Taylor? Becuse what Talyor said made me think they drove other car, so the squadron doesn't need to pick them up…

    “Just follow my car, Retendo!”

  11. It feels cheap.

    Why had someone done this, and how? And most importantly, who?

  12. I wasn't hooked to the story. I don't really care who caused the explotion. Though, keep in mind that it might be the english o_o"

@@Wanheda

  1. I agree with the "lazily" being an awkward way to explain how she answered the phone. Also, how you explained her eating the doughnut seemed quite jumbled and wordy. I can't tell if you mean that she ripped it open with her hands (which makes more since, but why would your dramatically rip up a messy food?) or if she used her mouth (she's on the phone so why do that?)
  2. To me, it makes more since to tell them to call a locksmith or roadside assistance to get back into the car, not insurance. I've never seen an insurance company come out to do it. They give your roadside assistance for a reason.
  3. Okay, for the goose. Why is it eating doughnuts? I have birds, you don't feed them that kind of thing because it will kill them. I am guessing the rules don't apply in this story, but thats really bothersome.
  4. How is she not fired?
  5. Okay so here we go. How is the duck wiping its own mouth? Does it use it's wings like hands and arms? Can it pick things up? "Jordan style" as in Michael Jordan the basketball player? Kicking it into the trash doesn't sound like a Michael Jordan move. A grinning goose? Again, I'm assuming the rules don't apply.
    6 I agree with the previous person on point number 4.
  6. She would have had her belt on her. It's part of the uniform. Even Correctional Officers have to wear them when they are on duty and they mostly sit around and escort prisoners.
  7. The way you worded the scene where she gets in the car implied that she got in the car with Taylor and not her own. The next line made it slightly confusing.
  8. "It’s not a very long drive to the crime scene, although neither of the pair know it yet." The last part isn't necessary.
  9. Someone bombing the building is in no way a lead. It's just stating what happened. It was also already addressed when she got to the building in the first place. It also doesn't make since that something that important would be stored in a small house. Why is it only halfway destroyed if it was a small house? Personally, my first thought was that it was a meth house that blew up.
  10. The short sentences made this really kinda annoying to read for me. Others may still enjoy it, but it's not my thing. I have to agree that I really wasn't interested in the story or what the characters are doing. The lack of descriptions about the characters and settings made it hard to picture. Keep working at it, I'm sure you can get it down.

Deleted user

A Name With No Girl:
Problem 1: Is 'answered the phone 'dully' a better way to say that?
Problem 2: I don't understand…
Problem 3: Jeremy messily wiped away the jelly, kicking the towel professional soccer style into the trash bin. Wanda applauded dimly. Is that better?
Problem 4: I fixed it.
Problem 5: I think I already referred to him as a 'goose' or 'bird' several times. Reread to see if I'm wrong?
Problem 6: It'll come fixed in the updated version.
Problem 7: Grammarly is my savior, fixed it
Problem 8: 'At least, it was to Wanda, who had read mystery books all her life.' Better?
Problem 9: It's in the updated version that I'll send later.
Problem 10: It's also in the updated version.
Problem 11: I agree. How about…'Who in Phillis City would have done this? The little lazy town in Canada was beginning to stir.' I'm open for more suggestions on that.
Problem 12: @@Wanheda pointed out the same thing, and she said it was about the character development. I'll try to work on that and any other thing you think needs work.
@@Wanheda:
Problem 1: Like I said, I switched it, do you think it's better?
Problem 2: I'm 12 so I know virtually nothing about that stuff, I changed it to Roadside Assistance, thanks.
(Also, PLEASE do not underestimate me because of my age. I came extremely close to publishing another book and I do NOT want to be looked down on because of my age factor. Don't judge me or my writing because of that.)
Problem 3: Jeremy is a strange case. This story is fiction, so the rules of the normal world don't apply. If you'd like, I'll try to make it clear that Jeremy is a special bird and not all birds are like him in the slightest.
Problem 4: I don't understand…
Problem 5: I changed it…again, the rules don't apply. How should I imply this more?
Problem 6: Okay, thanks. What would Taylor give her for patrol - or would she not give her anything?
Problem 7: Yeah, I'm fixing it in the updated version, which will come in just a little bit.
Problem 8: I'm trying to add the element of suspense, and from the articles from authors such as Lee Child and Mary Higgins Clark, you're supposed to keep the reader one step ahead of the character, or vice verse - they can never be at the same level. So, I'm trying to make it seem like the reader knows something the character doesn't. Still, don't like it? How can I fix it while keeping the suspense?
Problem 9: I fixed the lead part, it'll come fixed in the updated version. Also, what do you mean about the 'important thing'? The bomb? If so, it was put in there for reasons that are yet to be explained but are not revealed yet.
If I asked you to elaborate on anything, go ahead and tell me. For anything else, hang tight until I post the updated version of this section.
Thanks, guys. I really had no idea that there was so much stuff that needed to be fixed! If you see virtually anything that could be better, please tell me. I want this to be the best it can be. Thanks so much.